CounterpediaExplore knowledge. Follow the sources.

Evidence graph

Heppner AI privilege ruling: governed claim lifecycle Back to record

Lines are owner-declared structured references rendered for reading. Nothing here infers, admits, verifies, or ranks.

An unresolved node means the reference was declared but the target artifact was not part of this bounded load.

Technical details
  • not_loaded — This material was not loaded for this view.
  • not_published — This material has not been published.
  • unsupported_artifact_family — This kind of material is not shown as a separate object here.
  • resolution_failed — This material could not be retrieved.
  • depth_limited — Further connections were not expanded in this view.

Evidence graph explorer

Show layer (drawing and text lists; hides only, never adds)
Show relationship types (drawing only; the text lists are unaffected)
has edition (Governed record relationships)has edition (Governed record relationships)includes source (Governed record relationships)contains relevant passage (Governed record relationships)contains relevant passage (Governed record relationships)contains relevant passage (Governed record relationships)contains relevant passage (Governed record relationships)has record event (Governed record relationships)has record event (Governed record relationships)has record event (Governed record relationships)has record event (Governed record relationships)contains claim (Governed record relationships)contains claim (Governed record relationships)candidate not admitted (Governed record relationships)candidate not admitted (Governed record relationships)has receipt (Governed record relationships)contains claim (Governed record relationships)has receipt (Governed record relationships)amends (Governed record relationships)verification report attached (Governed record relationships)verification report attached (Governed record relationships)derived from record event (Governed record relationships)cites (Governed record relationships)cites (Governed record relationships)cites (Governed record relationships)cites (Governed record relationships)supported by (Governed record relationships)supported by (Governed record relationships)supported by (Governed record relationships)Heppner AI privilege ruling: governed claim lifecycle — Record (HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001)Heppner AIprivilege…RECORDEdition 1, released July 12, 2026 — Edition (HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EDITION-INITIAL)Edition 1,released July…EDITIONEdition 2, released July 12, 2026 — Edition (HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EDITION-REVISED)Edition 2,released July…EDITIONUnited States v. Heppner, document 27 — Source (PUBLIC-SRC-HEPPNER-DOC27)United States v.Heppner,…SOURCEthe written exchanges were not protected by either the attorney-client privilege or the work product doctrine — Relevant passage (span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p1:ruling)the writtenexchanges were…RELEVANT PASSAGEBecause Claude is not an attorney, that alone disposes of Heppner's claim of privilege — Relevant passage (span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p5:claude-not-attorney)Because Claudeis not an…RELEVANT PASSAGEthe documents were not prepared by or at the behest of counsel, nor did they reflect defense counsel's strategy — Relevant passage (span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p9:work-product-behest)the documentswere not…RELEVANT PASSAGEHeppner's use of Claude fails to satisfy either of these rules — Relevant passage (span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p12:case-specific-conclusion)Heppner's use ofClaude fails to…RELEVANT PASSAGECandidate created on July 12, 2026 — Record event (HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-CANDIDATES)Candidatecreated on July…RECORD EVENTEdition released on July 12, 2026 — Record event (HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-INITIAL)Edition releasedon July 12, 2026RECORD EVENTRevised on July 12, 2026 — Record event (HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-REOPENED)Revised on July12, 2026RECORD EVENTExported on July 12, 2026 — Record event (HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-VERIFIED)Exported on July12, 2026RECORD EVENTThe court ruled that Heppner's AI Documents were protected by neither attorney-client privilege nor the work product doctrine. — Claim (candidate:heppner:ruling)The court ruledthat Heppner's…CLAIMThe court concluded that Claude was not an attorney and treated that fact as sufficient to defeat Heppner's attorney-client privilege claim. — Claim (candidate:heppner:claude-not-attorney)The courtconcluded that…CLAIMCandidate not admitted — Candidate not admitted (candidate:heppner:universal-ai-privilege-rule)Candidate notadmittedCANDIDATE NOT A…Candidate not admitted — Candidate not admitted (candidate:heppner:work-product-behest)Candidate notadmittedCANDIDATE NOT A…Receipt: selection, quotation, refusal — Receipt (sovereignty_receipt:heppner-public-proof.v0_1:initial)Receipt:selection,…RECEIPTThe work-product ruling rested in part on the AI Documents not being prepared by or at the behest of counsel and not reflecting counsel's strategy. — Claim (candidate:heppner:work-product-behest)The work-productruling rested i…CLAIMReceipt: selection, quotation, refusal — Receipt (sovereignty_receipt:heppner-public-proof.v0_1:revised)Receipt:selection,…RECEIPTVerification report · Initial stage — Verification report (sha256:1ee1fccd38c53678aeee15363e0579cee19a0a19c8455afe2d385b0f3a18a3a2)Verificationreport · Initia…VERIFICATION RE…Verification report · Revised stage — Verification report (sha256:80c18726679e72c53bd13e0b56bc36f98fa21d0f6ad4a5da929746f7cb315fcf)Verificationreport · Revise…VERIFICATION RE…Referenced material not loaded — expected Source — Referenced material not loaded (["source","source:heppner:doc27"])Referencedmaterial not…REFERENCED MATE…

Legend

  • Governed record relationships (solid)
  • Countergraph traversal (dashed)
  • Countergraph evidence (dotted)
  • Observed provider relationships (dash-dot)
  • Structurally derived (sparse dots)

Node shape identifies node kind only. Size, color, and position carry no meaning beyond hop distance from the root.

A line means a supported artifact carried an explicit structured relation. It does not mean the relation is true, admitted, verified, or authoritative.

Graph as text

Nodes (22)

  • Heppner AI privilege ruling: governed claim lifecycle — Record
    Technical details
    ref
    ["record","counterpedia-public","HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001"]
    stable_ref
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001
    kind
    record
    plane
    governed_semantic
    source_fields
    anchor_resolution_status, control_discharge, corpus_lifecycle, current_edition, discovery_posture, disputes, exports, intersections, page_id, profile, projections, provenance, record_id, redaction, rendered_at, route_slug, slug, status, subtitle, title
    provenance
    artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EDITION-INITIAL, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as, source_field=record.editions; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EDITION-REVISED, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as, source_field=record.editions; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=PUBLIC-SRC-HEPPNER-DOC27, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as, source_field=record.sources; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p1:ruling, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as, source_field=record.citation_spans; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p5:claude-not-attorney, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as, source_field=record.citation_spans; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p9:work-product-behest, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as, source_field=record.citation_spans; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p12:case-specific-conclusion, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as, source_field=record.citation_spans; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-CANDIDATES, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as, source_field=record.lineage; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-INITIAL, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as, source_field=record.lineage; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-REOPENED, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as, source_field=record.lineage; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-VERIFIED, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as, source_field=record.lineage; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=candidate:heppner:ruling, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as, source_field=record.claim_lifecycle.initial_state.admitted_claims; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=candidate:heppner:claude-not-attorney, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as, source_field=record.claim_lifecycle.initial_state.admitted_claims; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=candidate:heppner:universal-ai-privilege-rule, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:refuses, source_field=record.claim_lifecycle.initial_state.refused_candidates; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=candidate:heppner:work-product-behest, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:refuses, source_field=record.claim_lifecycle.initial_state.refused_candidates; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=sovereignty_receipt:heppner-public-proof.v0_1:initial, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as, source_field=record.claim_lifecycle.initial_state.receipt; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=candidate:heppner:work-product-behest, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as, source_field=record.claim_lifecycle.revised_state.admitted_claims; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=sovereignty_receipt:heppner-public-proof.v0_1:revised, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as, source_field=record.claim_lifecycle.revised_state.receipt; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=candidate:heppner:work-product-behest, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:amends, source_field=record.claim_lifecycle.reopening.candidate_ref; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=/garpedia/verification-reports/HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001-initial.report.json, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:verified_by, source_field=record.verification_reports; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=/garpedia/verification-reports/HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001-revised.report.json, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:verified_by, source_field=record.verification_reports
    node_id
    ["record","counterpedia-public","HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001"]
    node_kind
    record
    source_plane
    governed_semantic
  • Edition 1, released July 12, 2026 — Edition
    Technical details
    ref
    ["edition","counterpedia-public","HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EDITION-INITIAL"]
    stable_ref
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EDITION-INITIAL
    kind
    edition
    plane
    governed_semantic
    source_fields
    edition_id, edition_number, released_at
    provenance
    artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EDITION-INITIAL, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as, source_field=record.editions
    node_id
    ["edition","counterpedia-public","HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EDITION-INITIAL"]
    node_kind
    edition
    source_plane
    governed_semantic
  • Edition 2, released July 12, 2026 — Edition
    Technical details
    ref
    ["edition","counterpedia-public","HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EDITION-REVISED"]
    stable_ref
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EDITION-REVISED
    kind
    edition
    plane
    governed_semantic
    source_fields
    amendment_kind, amendment_summary, edition_id, edition_number, produced_by_event_ids, released_at
    provenance
    artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EDITION-REVISED, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as, source_field=record.editions; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-REOPENED, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:derived_from, source_field=record.editions[1].produced_by_event_ids
    node_id
    ["edition","counterpedia-public","HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EDITION-REVISED"]
    node_kind
    edition
    source_plane
    governed_semantic
  • United States v. Heppner, document 27 — Source
    Technical details
    ref
    ["source","counterpedia-public","PUBLIC-SRC-HEPPNER-DOC27"]
    stable_ref
    PUBLIC-SRC-HEPPNER-DOC27
    kind
    source
    plane
    governed_semantic
    source_fields
    capture_hash, capture_integrity, description, label, publication_status, slug, source_id, source_type, span_ids
    raw_codes
    Source type code: filing; Publication status code: public
    provenance
    artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=PUBLIC-SRC-HEPPNER-DOC27, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as, source_field=record.sources; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=PUBLIC-SRC-HEPPNER-DOC27, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:cites, source_field=record.citation_spans[0].source_id; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=PUBLIC-SRC-HEPPNER-DOC27, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:cites, source_field=record.citation_spans[1].source_id; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=PUBLIC-SRC-HEPPNER-DOC27, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:cites, source_field=record.citation_spans[2].source_id; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=PUBLIC-SRC-HEPPNER-DOC27, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:cites, source_field=record.citation_spans[3].source_id
    node_id
    ["source","counterpedia-public","PUBLIC-SRC-HEPPNER-DOC27"]
    node_kind
    source
    source_plane
    governed_semantic
  • the written exchanges were not protected by either the attorney-client privilege or the work product doctrine — Relevant passage
    Technical details
    ref
    ["citationSpan","counterpedia-public","span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p1:ruling"]
    stable_ref
    span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p1:ruling
    kind
    citationSpan
    plane
    governed_semantic
    source_fields
    fragment_id, notes, source_id, span_id, supports_section_id, text, verification_state
    provenance
    artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p1:ruling, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as, source_field=record.citation_spans; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=PUBLIC-SRC-HEPPNER-DOC27, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:cites, source_field=record.citation_spans[0].source_id
    node_id
    ["citationSpan","counterpedia-public","span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p1:ruling"]
    node_kind
    citationSpan
    source_plane
    governed_semantic
  • Because Claude is not an attorney, that alone disposes of Heppner's claim of privilege — Relevant passage
    Technical details
    ref
    ["citationSpan","counterpedia-public","span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p5:claude-not-attorney"]
    stable_ref
    span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p5:claude-not-attorney
    kind
    citationSpan
    plane
    governed_semantic
    source_fields
    fragment_id, notes, source_id, span_id, supports_section_id, text, verification_state
    provenance
    artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p5:claude-not-attorney, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as, source_field=record.citation_spans; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=PUBLIC-SRC-HEPPNER-DOC27, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:cites, source_field=record.citation_spans[1].source_id
    node_id
    ["citationSpan","counterpedia-public","span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p5:claude-not-attorney"]
    node_kind
    citationSpan
    source_plane
    governed_semantic
  • the documents were not prepared by or at the behest of counsel, nor did they reflect defense counsel's strategy — Relevant passage
    Technical details
    ref
    ["citationSpan","counterpedia-public","span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p9:work-product-behest"]
    stable_ref
    span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p9:work-product-behest
    kind
    citationSpan
    plane
    governed_semantic
    source_fields
    fragment_id, notes, source_id, span_id, supports_section_id, text, verification_state
    provenance
    artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p9:work-product-behest, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as, source_field=record.citation_spans; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=PUBLIC-SRC-HEPPNER-DOC27, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:cites, source_field=record.citation_spans[2].source_id
    node_id
    ["citationSpan","counterpedia-public","span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p9:work-product-behest"]
    node_kind
    citationSpan
    source_plane
    governed_semantic
  • Heppner's use of Claude fails to satisfy either of these rules — Relevant passage
    Technical details
    ref
    ["citationSpan","counterpedia-public","span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p12:case-specific-conclusion"]
    stable_ref
    span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p12:case-specific-conclusion
    kind
    citationSpan
    plane
    governed_semantic
    source_fields
    fragment_id, notes, source_id, span_id, supports_section_id, text, verification_state
    provenance
    artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p12:case-specific-conclusion, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as, source_field=record.citation_spans; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=PUBLIC-SRC-HEPPNER-DOC27, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:cites, source_field=record.citation_spans[3].source_id
    node_id
    ["citationSpan","counterpedia-public","span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p12:case-specific-conclusion"]
    node_kind
    citationSpan
    source_plane
    governed_semantic
  • Candidate created on July 12, 2026 — Record event
    Technical details
    ref
    ["lifecycleEvent","counterpedia-public","HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-CANDIDATES"]
    stable_ref
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-CANDIDATES
    kind
    lifecycleEvent
    plane
    governed_semantic
    source_fields
    actor_role, detail, event_id, event_type, occurred_at
    raw_codes
    Event type code: candidate_created
    provenance
    artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-CANDIDATES, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as, source_field=record.lineage
    node_id
    ["lifecycleEvent","counterpedia-public","HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-CANDIDATES"]
    node_kind
    lifecycleEvent
    source_plane
    governed_semantic
  • Edition released on July 12, 2026 — Record event
    Technical details
    ref
    ["lifecycleEvent","counterpedia-public","HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-INITIAL"]
    stable_ref
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-INITIAL
    kind
    lifecycleEvent
    plane
    governed_semantic
    source_fields
    actor_role, detail, event_id, event_type, occurred_at
    raw_codes
    Event type code: edition_released
    provenance
    artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-INITIAL, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as, source_field=record.lineage
    node_id
    ["lifecycleEvent","counterpedia-public","HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-INITIAL"]
    node_kind
    lifecycleEvent
    source_plane
    governed_semantic
  • Revised on July 12, 2026 — Record event
    Technical details
    ref
    ["lifecycleEvent","counterpedia-public","HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-REOPENED"]
    stable_ref
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-REOPENED
    kind
    lifecycleEvent
    plane
    governed_semantic
    source_fields
    actor_role, detail, event_id, event_type, occurred_at
    raw_codes
    Event type code: revised
    provenance
    artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-REOPENED, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as, source_field=record.lineage; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-REOPENED, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:derived_from, source_field=record.editions[1].produced_by_event_ids
    node_id
    ["lifecycleEvent","counterpedia-public","HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-REOPENED"]
    node_kind
    lifecycleEvent
    source_plane
    governed_semantic
  • Exported on July 12, 2026 — Record event
    Technical details
    ref
    ["lifecycleEvent","counterpedia-public","HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-VERIFIED"]
    stable_ref
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-VERIFIED
    kind
    lifecycleEvent
    plane
    governed_semantic
    source_fields
    actor_role, detail, event_id, event_type, occurred_at
    raw_codes
    Event type code: exported
    provenance
    artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-VERIFIED, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as, source_field=record.lineage
    node_id
    ["lifecycleEvent","counterpedia-public","HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-VERIFIED"]
    node_kind
    lifecycleEvent
    source_plane
    governed_semantic
  • The court ruled that Heppner's AI Documents were protected by neither attorney-client privilege nor the work product doctrine. — Claim
    Technical details
    ref
    ["claim","counterpedia-public","candidate:heppner:ruling"]
    stable_ref
    candidate:heppner:ruling
    kind
    claim
    plane
    governed_semantic
    source_fields
    anchor_refs, candidate_ref, source_refs, text
    provenance
    artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=candidate:heppner:ruling, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as, source_field=record.claim_lifecycle.initial_state.admitted_claims; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=source:heppner:doc27, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:supported_by, source_field=record.claim_lifecycle.initial_state.admitted_claims[0].source_refs
    node_id
    ["claim","counterpedia-public","candidate:heppner:ruling"]
    node_kind
    claim
    source_plane
    governed_semantic
  • The court concluded that Claude was not an attorney and treated that fact as sufficient to defeat Heppner's attorney-client privilege claim. — Claim
    Technical details
    ref
    ["claim","counterpedia-public","candidate:heppner:claude-not-attorney"]
    stable_ref
    candidate:heppner:claude-not-attorney
    kind
    claim
    plane
    governed_semantic
    source_fields
    anchor_refs, candidate_ref, source_refs, text
    provenance
    artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=candidate:heppner:claude-not-attorney, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as, source_field=record.claim_lifecycle.initial_state.admitted_claims; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=source:heppner:doc27, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:supported_by, source_field=record.claim_lifecycle.initial_state.admitted_claims[1].source_refs
    node_id
    ["claim","counterpedia-public","candidate:heppner:claude-not-attorney"]
    node_kind
    claim
    source_plane
    governed_semantic
  • Candidate not admitted (title not available) — Candidate not admitted
    Technical details
    ref
    ["refusedCandidate","counterpedia-public","candidate:heppner:universal-ai-privilege-rule"]
    stable_ref
    candidate:heppner:universal-ai-privilege-rule
    kind
    refusedCandidate
    plane
    governed_semantic
    source_fields
    candidate_ref, lifecycle, reason
    provenance
    artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=candidate:heppner:universal-ai-privilege-rule, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:refuses, source_field=record.claim_lifecycle.initial_state.refused_candidates
    node_id
    ["refusedCandidate","counterpedia-public","candidate:heppner:universal-ai-privilege-rule"]
    node_kind
    refusedCandidate
    source_plane
    governed_semantic
  • Candidate not admitted (title not available) — Candidate not admitted
    Technical details
    ref
    ["refusedCandidate","counterpedia-public","candidate:heppner:work-product-behest"]
    stable_ref
    candidate:heppner:work-product-behest
    kind
    refusedCandidate
    plane
    governed_semantic
    source_fields
    candidate_ref, lifecycle, reason, reconsiderability_trigger
    provenance
    artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=candidate:heppner:work-product-behest, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:refuses, source_field=record.claim_lifecycle.initial_state.refused_candidates; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=candidate:heppner:work-product-behest, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:amends, source_field=record.claim_lifecycle.reopening.candidate_ref
    node_id
    ["refusedCandidate","counterpedia-public","candidate:heppner:work-product-behest"]
    node_kind
    refusedCandidate
    source_plane
    governed_semantic
  • Receipt: selection, quotation, refusal — Receipt
    Technical details
    ref
    ["receipt","counterpedia-public","sovereignty_receipt:heppner-public-proof.v0_1:initial"]
    stable_ref
    sovereignty_receipt:heppner-public-proof.v0_1:initial
    kind
    receipt
    plane
    governed_semantic
    source_fields
    artifact_hashes, operation_kinds, receipt_id
    provenance
    artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=sovereignty_receipt:heppner-public-proof.v0_1:initial, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as, source_field=record.claim_lifecycle.initial_state.receipt
    node_id
    ["receipt","counterpedia-public","sovereignty_receipt:heppner-public-proof.v0_1:initial"]
    node_kind
    receipt
    source_plane
    governed_semantic
  • The work-product ruling rested in part on the AI Documents not being prepared by or at the behest of counsel and not reflecting counsel's strategy. — Claim
    Technical details
    ref
    ["claim","counterpedia-public","candidate:heppner:work-product-behest"]
    stable_ref
    candidate:heppner:work-product-behest
    kind
    claim
    plane
    governed_semantic
    source_fields
    anchor_refs, candidate_ref, source_refs, text
    provenance
    artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=candidate:heppner:work-product-behest, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as, source_field=record.claim_lifecycle.revised_state.admitted_claims; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=source:heppner:doc27, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:supported_by, source_field=record.claim_lifecycle.revised_state.admitted_claims[2].source_refs
    node_id
    ["claim","counterpedia-public","candidate:heppner:work-product-behest"]
    node_kind
    claim
    source_plane
    governed_semantic
  • Receipt: selection, quotation, refusal — Receipt
    Technical details
    ref
    ["receipt","counterpedia-public","sovereignty_receipt:heppner-public-proof.v0_1:revised"]
    stable_ref
    sovereignty_receipt:heppner-public-proof.v0_1:revised
    kind
    receipt
    plane
    governed_semantic
    source_fields
    artifact_hashes, operation_kinds, receipt_id
    provenance
    artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=sovereignty_receipt:heppner-public-proof.v0_1:revised, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as, source_field=record.claim_lifecycle.revised_state.receipt
    node_id
    ["receipt","counterpedia-public","sovereignty_receipt:heppner-public-proof.v0_1:revised"]
    node_kind
    receipt
    source_plane
    governed_semantic
  • Verification report · Initial stage — Verification report
    Technical details
    ref
    ["verificationReport","counterpedia-public","sha256:1ee1fccd38c53678aeee15363e0579cee19a0a19c8455afe2d385b0f3a18a3a2"]
    stable_ref
    sha256:1ee1fccd38c53678aeee15363e0579cee19a0a19c8455afe2d385b0f3a18a3a2
    kind
    verificationReport
    plane
    governed_semantic
    source_fields
    boundary_note, conclusions, findings, owner, passed, public_path, report_hash, schema, stage, verification_profile, verified_artifacts
    digest
    sha256:1ee1fccd38c53678aeee15363e0579cee19a0a19c8455afe2d385b0f3a18a3a2
    raw_codes
    Verification profile code: full_artifact_chain.v0_1; Stage code: initial
    provenance
    artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=/garpedia/verification-reports/HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001-initial.report.json, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:verified_by, source_field=record.verification_reports
    node_id
    ["verificationReport","counterpedia-public","sha256:1ee1fccd38c53678aeee15363e0579cee19a0a19c8455afe2d385b0f3a18a3a2"]
    node_kind
    verificationReport
    source_plane
    governed_semantic
  • Verification report · Revised stage — Verification report
    Technical details
    ref
    ["verificationReport","counterpedia-public","sha256:80c18726679e72c53bd13e0b56bc36f98fa21d0f6ad4a5da929746f7cb315fcf"]
    stable_ref
    sha256:80c18726679e72c53bd13e0b56bc36f98fa21d0f6ad4a5da929746f7cb315fcf
    kind
    verificationReport
    plane
    governed_semantic
    source_fields
    boundary_note, conclusions, findings, owner, passed, public_path, report_hash, schema, stage, verification_profile, verified_artifacts
    digest
    sha256:80c18726679e72c53bd13e0b56bc36f98fa21d0f6ad4a5da929746f7cb315fcf
    raw_codes
    Verification profile code: full_artifact_chain.v0_1; Stage code: revised
    provenance
    artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=/garpedia/verification-reports/HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001-revised.report.json, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:verified_by, source_field=record.verification_reports
    node_id
    ["verificationReport","counterpedia-public","sha256:80c18726679e72c53bd13e0b56bc36f98fa21d0f6ad4a5da929746f7cb315fcf"]
    node_kind
    verificationReport
    source_plane
    governed_semantic
  • Referenced material not loaded — expected Source — Referenced material not loaded
    Technical details
    ref
    ["unresolvedReference","counterpedia-public","[\"source\",\"source:heppner:doc27\"]"]
    stable_ref
    ["source","source:heppner:doc27"]
    kind
    unresolvedReference
    plane
    governed_semantic
    source_fields
    declared_node_kind, declared_reference, declared_stable_id, reason
    raw_codes
    Reason code: unsupported_artifact_family
    provenance
    artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=source:heppner:doc27, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:supported_by, source_field=record.claim_lifecycle.initial_state.admitted_claims[0].source_refs; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=source:heppner:doc27, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:supported_by, source_field=record.claim_lifecycle.initial_state.admitted_claims[1].source_refs; artifact_family=page_model, artifact_identity=HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001, declared_reference=source:heppner:doc27, plane=governed_semantic, predicate_ref=garpedia:graph:predicate:supported_by, source_field=record.claim_lifecycle.revised_state.admitted_claims[2].source_refs
    node_id
    ["unresolvedReference","counterpedia-public","[\"source\",\"source:heppner:doc27\"]"]
    node_kind
    unresolvedReference
    source_plane
    governed_semantic

Edges (29)

  • Heppner AI privilege ruling: governed claim lifecycle — has edition → Edition 1, released July 12, 2026 — Governed record relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    projects_as
    plane
    governed_semantic
    edge_id
    ["projects_as","[\"record\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001\"]","[\"edition\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EDITION-INITIAL\"]"]
    artifact_family
    page_model
    artifact_identity
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001
    source_field
    record.editions
    source_index
    0
    declared_reference
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EDITION-INITIAL
    predicate_ref
    garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as
  • Heppner AI privilege ruling: governed claim lifecycle — has edition → Edition 2, released July 12, 2026 — Governed record relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    projects_as
    plane
    governed_semantic
    edge_id
    ["projects_as","[\"record\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001\"]","[\"edition\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EDITION-REVISED\"]"]
    artifact_family
    page_model
    artifact_identity
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001
    source_field
    record.editions
    source_index
    1
    declared_reference
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EDITION-REVISED
    predicate_ref
    garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as
  • Heppner AI privilege ruling: governed claim lifecycle — includes source → United States v. Heppner, document 27 — Governed record relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    projects_as
    plane
    governed_semantic
    edge_id
    ["projects_as","[\"record\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001\"]","[\"source\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"PUBLIC-SRC-HEPPNER-DOC27\"]"]
    artifact_family
    page_model
    artifact_identity
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001
    source_field
    record.sources
    source_index
    0
    declared_reference
    PUBLIC-SRC-HEPPNER-DOC27
    predicate_ref
    garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as
  • Heppner AI privilege ruling: governed claim lifecycle — contains relevant passage → the written exchanges were not protected by either the attorney-client privilege or the work product doctrine — Governed record relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    projects_as
    plane
    governed_semantic
    edge_id
    ["projects_as","[\"record\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001\"]","[\"citationSpan\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p1:ruling\"]"]
    artifact_family
    page_model
    artifact_identity
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001
    source_field
    record.citation_spans
    source_index
    0
    declared_reference
    span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p1:ruling
    predicate_ref
    garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as
  • Heppner AI privilege ruling: governed claim lifecycle — contains relevant passage → Because Claude is not an attorney, that alone disposes of Heppner's claim of privilege — Governed record relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    projects_as
    plane
    governed_semantic
    edge_id
    ["projects_as","[\"record\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001\"]","[\"citationSpan\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p5:claude-not-attorney\"]"]
    artifact_family
    page_model
    artifact_identity
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001
    source_field
    record.citation_spans
    source_index
    1
    declared_reference
    span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p5:claude-not-attorney
    predicate_ref
    garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as
  • Heppner AI privilege ruling: governed claim lifecycle — contains relevant passage → the documents were not prepared by or at the behest of counsel, nor did they reflect defense counsel's strategy — Governed record relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    projects_as
    plane
    governed_semantic
    edge_id
    ["projects_as","[\"record\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001\"]","[\"citationSpan\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p9:work-product-behest\"]"]
    artifact_family
    page_model
    artifact_identity
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001
    source_field
    record.citation_spans
    source_index
    2
    declared_reference
    span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p9:work-product-behest
    predicate_ref
    garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as
  • Heppner AI privilege ruling: governed claim lifecycle — contains relevant passage → Heppner's use of Claude fails to satisfy either of these rules — Governed record relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    projects_as
    plane
    governed_semantic
    edge_id
    ["projects_as","[\"record\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001\"]","[\"citationSpan\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p12:case-specific-conclusion\"]"]
    artifact_family
    page_model
    artifact_identity
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001
    source_field
    record.citation_spans
    source_index
    3
    declared_reference
    span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p12:case-specific-conclusion
    predicate_ref
    garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as
  • Heppner AI privilege ruling: governed claim lifecycle — has record event → Candidate created on July 12, 2026 — Governed record relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    projects_as
    plane
    governed_semantic
    edge_id
    ["projects_as","[\"record\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001\"]","[\"lifecycleEvent\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-CANDIDATES\"]"]
    artifact_family
    page_model
    artifact_identity
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001
    source_field
    record.lineage
    source_index
    0
    declared_reference
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-CANDIDATES
    predicate_ref
    garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as
  • Heppner AI privilege ruling: governed claim lifecycle — has record event → Edition released on July 12, 2026 — Governed record relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    projects_as
    plane
    governed_semantic
    edge_id
    ["projects_as","[\"record\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001\"]","[\"lifecycleEvent\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-INITIAL\"]"]
    artifact_family
    page_model
    artifact_identity
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001
    source_field
    record.lineage
    source_index
    1
    declared_reference
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-INITIAL
    predicate_ref
    garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as
  • Heppner AI privilege ruling: governed claim lifecycle — has record event → Revised on July 12, 2026 — Governed record relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    projects_as
    plane
    governed_semantic
    edge_id
    ["projects_as","[\"record\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001\"]","[\"lifecycleEvent\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-REOPENED\"]"]
    artifact_family
    page_model
    artifact_identity
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001
    source_field
    record.lineage
    source_index
    2
    declared_reference
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-REOPENED
    predicate_ref
    garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as
  • Heppner AI privilege ruling: governed claim lifecycle — has record event → Exported on July 12, 2026 — Governed record relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    projects_as
    plane
    governed_semantic
    edge_id
    ["projects_as","[\"record\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001\"]","[\"lifecycleEvent\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-VERIFIED\"]"]
    artifact_family
    page_model
    artifact_identity
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001
    source_field
    record.lineage
    source_index
    3
    declared_reference
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-VERIFIED
    predicate_ref
    garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as
  • Heppner AI privilege ruling: governed claim lifecycle — contains claim → The court ruled that Heppner's AI Documents were protected by neither attorney-client privilege nor the work product doctrine. — Governed record relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    projects_as
    plane
    governed_semantic
    edge_id
    ["projects_as","[\"record\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001\"]","[\"claim\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"candidate:heppner:ruling\"]"]
    artifact_family
    page_model
    artifact_identity
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001
    source_field
    record.claim_lifecycle.initial_state.admitted_claims
    source_index
    0
    declared_reference
    candidate:heppner:ruling
    predicate_ref
    garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as
  • Heppner AI privilege ruling: governed claim lifecycle — contains claim → The court concluded that Claude was not an attorney and treated that fact as sufficient to defeat Heppner's attorney-client privilege claim. — Governed record relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    projects_as
    plane
    governed_semantic
    edge_id
    ["projects_as","[\"record\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001\"]","[\"claim\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"candidate:heppner:claude-not-attorney\"]"]
    artifact_family
    page_model
    artifact_identity
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001
    source_field
    record.claim_lifecycle.initial_state.admitted_claims
    source_index
    1
    declared_reference
    candidate:heppner:claude-not-attorney
    predicate_ref
    garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as
  • Heppner AI privilege ruling: governed claim lifecycle — candidate not admitted → Candidate not admitted — Governed record relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    refuses
    plane
    governed_semantic
    edge_id
    ["refuses","[\"record\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001\"]","[\"refusedCandidate\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"candidate:heppner:universal-ai-privilege-rule\"]"]
    artifact_family
    page_model
    artifact_identity
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001
    source_field
    record.claim_lifecycle.initial_state.refused_candidates
    source_index
    0
    declared_reference
    candidate:heppner:universal-ai-privilege-rule
    predicate_ref
    garpedia:graph:predicate:refuses
  • Heppner AI privilege ruling: governed claim lifecycle — candidate not admitted → Candidate not admitted — Governed record relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    refuses
    plane
    governed_semantic
    edge_id
    ["refuses","[\"record\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001\"]","[\"refusedCandidate\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"candidate:heppner:work-product-behest\"]"]
    artifact_family
    page_model
    artifact_identity
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001
    source_field
    record.claim_lifecycle.initial_state.refused_candidates
    source_index
    1
    declared_reference
    candidate:heppner:work-product-behest
    predicate_ref
    garpedia:graph:predicate:refuses
  • Heppner AI privilege ruling: governed claim lifecycle — has receipt → Receipt: selection, quotation, refusal — Governed record relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    projects_as
    plane
    governed_semantic
    edge_id
    ["projects_as","[\"record\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001\"]","[\"receipt\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"sovereignty_receipt:heppner-public-proof.v0_1:initial\"]"]
    artifact_family
    page_model
    artifact_identity
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001
    source_field
    record.claim_lifecycle.initial_state.receipt
    declared_reference
    sovereignty_receipt:heppner-public-proof.v0_1:initial
    predicate_ref
    garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as
  • Heppner AI privilege ruling: governed claim lifecycle — contains claim → The work-product ruling rested in part on the AI Documents not being prepared by or at the behest of counsel and not reflecting counsel's strategy. — Governed record relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    projects_as
    plane
    governed_semantic
    edge_id
    ["projects_as","[\"record\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001\"]","[\"claim\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"candidate:heppner:work-product-behest\"]"]
    artifact_family
    page_model
    artifact_identity
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001
    source_field
    record.claim_lifecycle.revised_state.admitted_claims
    source_index
    2
    declared_reference
    candidate:heppner:work-product-behest
    predicate_ref
    garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as
  • Heppner AI privilege ruling: governed claim lifecycle — has receipt → Receipt: selection, quotation, refusal — Governed record relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    projects_as
    plane
    governed_semantic
    edge_id
    ["projects_as","[\"record\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001\"]","[\"receipt\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"sovereignty_receipt:heppner-public-proof.v0_1:revised\"]"]
    artifact_family
    page_model
    artifact_identity
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001
    source_field
    record.claim_lifecycle.revised_state.receipt
    declared_reference
    sovereignty_receipt:heppner-public-proof.v0_1:revised
    predicate_ref
    garpedia:graph:predicate:projects_as
  • Heppner AI privilege ruling: governed claim lifecycle — amends → Candidate not admitted — Governed record relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    amends
    plane
    governed_semantic
    edge_id
    ["amends","[\"record\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001\"]","[\"refusedCandidate\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"candidate:heppner:work-product-behest\"]"]
    artifact_family
    page_model
    artifact_identity
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001
    source_field
    record.claim_lifecycle.reopening.candidate_ref
    declared_reference
    candidate:heppner:work-product-behest
    predicate_ref
    garpedia:graph:predicate:amends
  • Heppner AI privilege ruling: governed claim lifecycle — verification report attached → Verification report · Initial stage — Governed record relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    verified_by
    plane
    governed_semantic
    edge_id
    ["verified_by","[\"record\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001\"]","[\"verificationReport\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"sha256:1ee1fccd38c53678aeee15363e0579cee19a0a19c8455afe2d385b0f3a18a3a2\"]"]
    artifact_family
    page_model
    artifact_identity
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001
    source_field
    record.verification_reports
    source_index
    0
    declared_reference
    /garpedia/verification-reports/HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001-initial.report.json
    predicate_ref
    garpedia:graph:predicate:verified_by
  • Heppner AI privilege ruling: governed claim lifecycle — verification report attached → Verification report · Revised stage — Governed record relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    verified_by
    plane
    governed_semantic
    edge_id
    ["verified_by","[\"record\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001\"]","[\"verificationReport\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"sha256:80c18726679e72c53bd13e0b56bc36f98fa21d0f6ad4a5da929746f7cb315fcf\"]"]
    artifact_family
    page_model
    artifact_identity
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001
    source_field
    record.verification_reports
    source_index
    1
    declared_reference
    /garpedia/verification-reports/HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001-revised.report.json
    predicate_ref
    garpedia:graph:predicate:verified_by
  • Edition 2, released July 12, 2026 — derived from record event → Revised on July 12, 2026 — Governed record relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    derived_from
    plane
    governed_semantic
    edge_id
    ["derived_from","[\"edition\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EDITION-REVISED\"]","[\"lifecycleEvent\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-REOPENED\"]"]
    artifact_family
    page_model
    artifact_identity
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001
    source_field
    record.editions[1].produced_by_event_ids
    source_index
    0
    declared_reference
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-EVENT-REOPENED
    predicate_ref
    garpedia:graph:predicate:derived_from
  • the written exchanges were not protected by either the attorney-client privilege or the work product doctrine — cites → United States v. Heppner, document 27 — Governed record relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    cites
    plane
    governed_semantic
    edge_id
    ["cites","[\"citationSpan\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p1:ruling\"]","[\"source\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"PUBLIC-SRC-HEPPNER-DOC27\"]"]
    artifact_family
    page_model
    artifact_identity
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001
    source_field
    record.citation_spans[0].source_id
    declared_reference
    PUBLIC-SRC-HEPPNER-DOC27
    predicate_ref
    garpedia:graph:predicate:cites
  • Because Claude is not an attorney, that alone disposes of Heppner's claim of privilege — cites → United States v. Heppner, document 27 — Governed record relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    cites
    plane
    governed_semantic
    edge_id
    ["cites","[\"citationSpan\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p5:claude-not-attorney\"]","[\"source\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"PUBLIC-SRC-HEPPNER-DOC27\"]"]
    artifact_family
    page_model
    artifact_identity
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001
    source_field
    record.citation_spans[1].source_id
    declared_reference
    PUBLIC-SRC-HEPPNER-DOC27
    predicate_ref
    garpedia:graph:predicate:cites
  • the documents were not prepared by or at the behest of counsel, nor did they reflect defense counsel's strategy — cites → United States v. Heppner, document 27 — Governed record relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    cites
    plane
    governed_semantic
    edge_id
    ["cites","[\"citationSpan\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p9:work-product-behest\"]","[\"source\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"PUBLIC-SRC-HEPPNER-DOC27\"]"]
    artifact_family
    page_model
    artifact_identity
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001
    source_field
    record.citation_spans[2].source_id
    declared_reference
    PUBLIC-SRC-HEPPNER-DOC27
    predicate_ref
    garpedia:graph:predicate:cites
  • Heppner's use of Claude fails to satisfy either of these rules — cites → United States v. Heppner, document 27 — Governed record relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    cites
    plane
    governed_semantic
    edge_id
    ["cites","[\"citationSpan\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"span:anchor:heppner:doc27:p12:case-specific-conclusion\"]","[\"source\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"PUBLIC-SRC-HEPPNER-DOC27\"]"]
    artifact_family
    page_model
    artifact_identity
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001
    source_field
    record.citation_spans[3].source_id
    declared_reference
    PUBLIC-SRC-HEPPNER-DOC27
    predicate_ref
    garpedia:graph:predicate:cites
  • The court ruled that Heppner's AI Documents were protected by neither attorney-client privilege nor the work product doctrine. — supported by → Referenced material not loaded — expected Source — Governed record relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    supported_by
    plane
    governed_semantic
    edge_id
    ["supported_by","[\"claim\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"candidate:heppner:ruling\"]","[\"unresolvedReference\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"[\\\"source\\\",\\\"source:heppner:doc27\\\"]\"]"]
    artifact_family
    page_model
    artifact_identity
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001
    source_field
    record.claim_lifecycle.initial_state.admitted_claims[0].source_refs
    source_index
    0
    declared_reference
    source:heppner:doc27
    predicate_ref
    garpedia:graph:predicate:supported_by
  • The court concluded that Claude was not an attorney and treated that fact as sufficient to defeat Heppner's attorney-client privilege claim. — supported by → Referenced material not loaded — expected Source — Governed record relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    supported_by
    plane
    governed_semantic
    edge_id
    ["supported_by","[\"claim\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"candidate:heppner:claude-not-attorney\"]","[\"unresolvedReference\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"[\\\"source\\\",\\\"source:heppner:doc27\\\"]\"]"]
    artifact_family
    page_model
    artifact_identity
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001
    source_field
    record.claim_lifecycle.initial_state.admitted_claims[1].source_refs
    source_index
    0
    declared_reference
    source:heppner:doc27
    predicate_ref
    garpedia:graph:predicate:supported_by
  • The work-product ruling rested in part on the AI Documents not being prepared by or at the behest of counsel and not reflecting counsel's strategy. — supported by → Referenced material not loaded — expected Source — Governed record relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    supported_by
    plane
    governed_semantic
    edge_id
    ["supported_by","[\"claim\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"candidate:heppner:work-product-behest\"]","[\"unresolvedReference\",\"counterpedia-public\",\"[\\\"source\\\",\\\"source:heppner:doc27\\\"]\"]"]
    artifact_family
    page_model
    artifact_identity
    HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001
    source_field
    record.claim_lifecycle.revised_state.admitted_claims[2].source_refs
    source_index
    0
    declared_reference
    source:heppner:doc27
    predicate_ref
    garpedia:graph:predicate:supported_by

Reader shortcuts (not graph edges) (0)

    Unresolved references (1)

    • Referenced material not loaded — expected Source. This kind of material is not shown as a separate object here.
      Technical detailsreason: unsupported_artifact_family — source source:heppner:doc27 — depth 2 — declared by ["claim","counterpedia-public","candidate:heppner:ruling"] — declared_reference: source:heppner:doc27

    Frontier (0)