Research source candidate · Not admitted
NeurIPS 2017 public reviews (PC-02 PAPER-S04)
Dossier reference AIAYN-S04
Authored research source candidate. Not yet a governed Counterpedia source.
Found in
- demo-corpus-wave2 / attention-is-all-you-need-demo-corpus-dossier-v0-3
Authored authority / posture: three reviewer texts published with the proceedings; each is one reviewer's judgment and request, not a collective certification of the paper's claims. Reviewer 1 reports reimplementing the work and calls it "a clear accept" while noting the learning-rate schedule "seems to really matter" (a reviewer's statement about reimplementation, not a separate reproduction record); Reviewer 2 notes the architecture advances state of the art by about 1 BLEU and asks about dropout and a dangling reference; a reviewer notes the lack of mathematical definition of multi-head attention and asks for evaluation on long sentences and for stronger validation of the long-range-dependency argument.
Authored priority: P0
Capture status
Capture status is not evaluated by this dossier view.
Governed source
No governed SourceEdition binding is carried by this view.