CounterpediaExplore knowledge. Follow the sources.

Branch lifecycle history

Lifecycle transitions for Heppner AI privilege ruling: governed claim lifecycle, rendered by stable branch identity. Each transition is a governed state change, not a prose edit. A FINAL branch remains terminal unless the governed model itself records otherwise.

Standing history

Lifecycle & reopening conditions

This rail projects governed standing and admission events already retained by the record. It is not a prose-edit diff. PROPOSED is a reader label for the governed candidate prior-state; REOPENED appears only as a recorded reopening event, never as a fabricated lifecycle state.

Lifecycle item 1

current: admitted

  1. PROPOSED · candidate

  2. ADMITTED

    Transition details
    previous → new
    candidate → admitted
    what changed
    The admitted projection changed.
    evidence / basis newly carried by target state
    source_ref=source:heppner:doc27 · anchor_ref=anchor:heppner:doc27:p5:claude-not-attorney
    receipt
    sovereignty_receipt:heppner-public-proof.v0_1:initial
    recorded at
    2026-07-12T00:00:00Z
Technical branch identity

candidate:heppner:claude-not-attorney

Lifecycle item 2

current: admitted

  1. PROPOSED · candidate

  2. ADMITTED

    Transition details
    previous → new
    candidate → admitted
    what changed
    The admitted projection changed.
    evidence / basis newly carried by target state
    source_ref=source:heppner:doc27 · anchor_ref=anchor:heppner:doc27:p1:ruling
    receipt
    sovereignty_receipt:heppner-public-proof.v0_1:initial
    recorded at
    2026-07-12T00:00:00Z
Technical branch identity

candidate:heppner:ruling

Lifecycle item 3

current: final

  1. PROPOSED · candidate

  2. FINAL REFUSAL

    Transition details
    previous → new
    candidate → final
    what changed
    Standing changed without changing the admitted projection.
    why
    final refusal: the universal proposition is broader than the case-specific memorandum and has no supporting anchor
    evidence / basis newly carried by target state
    No newly carried evidence reference is recorded on this transition projection.
    receipt
    sovereignty_receipt:heppner-public-proof.v0_1:initial
    recorded at
    2026-07-12T00:00:00Z
Technical branch identity

candidate:heppner:universal-ai-privilege-rule

Lifecycle item 4

current: admitted

  1. PROPOSED · candidate

  2. REFUSED · reconsiderable

    Transition details
    previous → new
    candidate → reconsiderable
    what changed
    Standing changed without changing the admitted projection.
    why
    reconsiderable refusal: the proposed source anchor is not in the initial admitted capture
    evidence / basis newly carried by target state
    No newly carried evidence reference is recorded on this transition projection.
    receipt
    sovereignty_receipt:heppner-public-proof.v0_1:initial
    recorded at
    2026-07-12T00:00:00Z

    This can reopen if: new_evidence_admitted

  3. REOPENED

    Reopening details
    why
    the supplemental public capture admitted the candidate's pinned page 9 anchor
    trigger
    new_evidence_admitted
    basis refs
    reopen:heppner:work-product-behest · reopening:reopen:heppner:work-product-behest

  4. ADMITTED

    Transition details
    previous → new
    reconsiderable → admitted
    what changed
    The admitted projection changed.
    evidence / basis newly carried by target state
    source_ref=source:heppner:doc27 · anchor_ref=anchor:heppner:doc27:p9:work-product-behest
    receipt
    sovereignty_receipt:heppner-public-proof.v0_1:revised
    trigger / basis
    reopen:heppner:work-product-behest · reopening:reopen:heppner:work-product-behest
    recorded at
    2026-07-12T00:00:00Z
Technical branch identity

candidate:heppner:work-product-behest

Admission lineage

terminal: retired

  1. superseded

    Event details
    recorded at
    2026-07-12
    why
    Public Heppner proofcase admitted for read-only lifecycle presentation after Amnesiac packet-time binding and separate ARCS Verify structural recomputation were committed and reproduced byte-for-byte. GARPedia presents the public artifacts and does not establish historical authenticity or signature validity.
    superseded by
    ADM-EVT-public:HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001-0002

  2. superseded

    Event details
    previous → new
    superseded → superseded
    recorded at
    2026-08-01
    why
    Re-admitted under the capture-integrity v2 migration (owner decision record CH-D1 through CH-D5). Source integrity is now declared explicitly: captured bytes carry a sha256 digest with a named referent, synthetic fixtures carry a non-digest fixture identity, and restricted or redacted sources with no custody artifact are recorded as unavailable. Placeholder digests and hash-shaped opaque identifiers were removed or renamed out of hash vocabulary. This re-admission records a representation change only. It asserts no authenticity, no signature validity, no verification outcome, and no new provenance beyond what the prior admission already carried.
    supersedes
    ADM-EVT-public:HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001-0001
    superseded by
    ADM-EVT-public:HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001-0003

  3. retired

    Event details
    previous → new
    superseded → retired
    recorded at
    2026-08-14
    why retired
    Owner decision: retire the Heppner proofcase from current public/admitted standing. Its admission history (events 0001 and 0002) is retained, not erased; this terminal event withdraws the lineage from serving without a replacement admission. The record bytes remain physically present for historical provenance but are no longer projected to any current public or showcase surface. Retirement asserts nothing about the prior admission's validity; it only ends current standing.
    supersedes
    ADM-EVT-public:HEPPNER-LIFECYCLE-0001-0002

candidate:heppner:claude-not-attorney

  1. Candidate toAdmitted

    time
    2026-07-12T00:00:00Z
    receipt reference
    sovereignty_receipt:heppner-public-proof.v0_1:initial
    changed admitted projection
    Yes

candidate:heppner:ruling

  1. Candidate toAdmitted

    time
    2026-07-12T00:00:00Z
    receipt reference
    sovereignty_receipt:heppner-public-proof.v0_1:initial
    changed admitted projection
    Yes

candidate:heppner:universal-ai-privilege-rule

Terminal — FINAL refusal

  1. Candidate toFINAL refusal

    time
    2026-07-12T00:00:00Z
    receipt reference
    sovereignty_receipt:heppner-public-proof.v0_1:initial
    changed admitted projection
    No

candidate:heppner:work-product-behest

  1. Candidate toReconsiderable

    time
    2026-07-12T00:00:00Z
    receipt reference
    sovereignty_receipt:heppner-public-proof.v0_1:initial
    changed admitted projection
    No

  2. Reconsiderable toAdmitted

    time
    2026-07-12T00:00:00Z
    trigger / decision reference
    reopen:heppner:work-product-behest · reopening:reopen:heppner:work-product-behest
    receipt reference
    sovereignty_receipt:heppner-public-proof.v0_1:revised
    changed admitted projection
    Yes