Counterpedia · Subject

Wikidata observation

The Holocaust Industry

essay by Norman Finkelstein

Also known as (1)

The Holocaust Industry. Reflections on the Exploitation of Jewish Suffering

Observations from Wikidata; separate from governed Counterpedia records. Sources, origins and what has been checked

At a glance

Selected recorded observations. Counterpedia has not independently verified them; inspect the statements for sources and alternative or historical context.

instance of: literary work
About this property
This names the relationship or attribute recorded by Wikidata. Any context shown beside it qualifies this particular statement.
Wikidata property P31; Statement & references
author: Norman Finkelstein
About this property
This names the relationship or attribute recorded by Wikidata. Any context shown beside it qualifies this particular statement.
Wikidata property P50; Statement & references
country of origin: United States
About this property
This names the relationship or attribute recorded by Wikidata. Any context shown beside it qualifies this particular statement.
Wikidata property P495; Statement & references
genre: essay
About this property
This names the relationship or attribute recorded by Wikidata. Any context shown beside it qualifies this particular statement.
Wikidata property P136; Statement & references
different from: Holocaust Industry
About this property
This names the relationship or attribute recorded by Wikidata. Any context shown beside it qualifies this particular statement.
Wikidata property P1889; Statement & references
influenced by: The Holocaust in American Life
About this property
This names the relationship or attribute recorded by Wikidata. Any context shown beside it qualifies this particular statement.
Wikidata property P737; Statement & references
main subject: Holocaust studies
About this property
This names the relationship or attribute recorded by Wikidata. Any context shown beside it qualifies this particular statement.
Wikidata property P921; Statement & references

How these facts are selected

Up to eight distinct properties with readable names and values. One from each available category comes first, then remaining slots follow property category, property code and source order. This keeps names and family details from crowding out work, dates and geography. Media, external identifiers, unnamed targets and statements with incomplete qualifying context stay in the detailed list. The same rule applies to every subject. Context recorded by Wikidata appears beside each selected fact.

Relationships

Outgoing connections are statements about this subject. A connection is not evidence that another subject supports a claim.

different from (P1889): Holocaust Industry
Relationship name unavailable: A Nation on Trial
main subject (P921): Holocaust studies
country of origin (P495): United States
genre (P136): essay
Relationship name unavailable: The Holocaust
genre (P136): non-fiction literature
influenced by (P737): The Holocaust in American Life
instance of (P31): literary work
Relationship name unavailable: Beyond Chutzpah
Relationship name unavailable: Verso Books
author (P50): Norman Finkelstein

All projected connections & provider records

You are here

The Holocaust Industry

Other entries this record states a relationship to. Follow one to keep moving through the universe.

Identity & relations

literary work— instance of (P31)stated relationship

Notable works

Norman Finkelstein— author (P50)stated relationship

Places

United States— country of origin (P495)stated relationship

Other connections

Holocaust Industry— different from (P1889)stated relationship
A Nation on Trial— P155stated relationship
Holocaust studies— main subject (P921)stated relationship
essay— genre (P136)stated relationship
The Holocaust— P840stated relationship
non-fiction literature— genre (P136)stated relationship
The Holocaust in American Life— influenced by (P737)stated relationship
Beyond Chutzpah— P156stated relationship
Verso Books— P123stated relationship

The original records this observation was assembled from, off Counterpedia.

Wikidata: Q1768389 ↗

Keep exploring the surrounding neighborhood.

Explore the The Holocaust Industry neighborhood

Assembled from entry read model wikimedia_observation:Q1768389, public release sha256:f33228901a35b0683356002a46df9ceb11f399d05f17abb5c7c78256cbf38ba7. This view is served from published release bytes.

Explore incoming and outgoing relationships →

External identifiers (8)

Identifier lookup links, separate from statement references.

P1144: 00043250
P243: 52486141
P646: /m/03l4n
IdRef / SUDOC: 076301524
VIAF: 193689400 ↗
Open Library: OL2733666W
P1085: 4805215
P5337: CAAqIQgKIhtDQkFTRGdvSUwyMHZNRE5zTkc0U0FtVnVLQUFQAQ

Sources and origins

Structured observations: Statements in this view were observed in Wikidata. Their source identifiers and carried history remain available for inspection.
Cited references: Works, URLs and identifiers attached to particular statements. A cited locator is not an independently established support finding. Inspect statement references
Retained evidence: This view carries observation data. It does not supply independently captured copies of the cited documents or establish their custody. Discovering a reference does not register a governed Source Record.
Checks: No completed Check is associated with these statements in this view. Check execution is currently unavailable.

These observations are not governed Counterpedia claims. The origin of an observation can differ from the author or publisher of its cited source.

Documentary coverage

Documentary identifiers

No source identifiers recorded

Identifiers Counterpedia can route

No lookup route known

Reference-route hints

Reference route hint recorded

“Routable” means Counterpedia knows an approved provider capability that can investigate the identifier. It does not mean the source has been captured or checked.

Validation state

1. In Wikidata
No source identifiers recorded.
2. Lookup route
No source identifiers recorded.
3. Lookup result
No lookup recorded for this page.
4. Saved copy
No saved copy for this page.
5. Fixed version
No fixed source version for this page.
6. Check result
Not checked.

These stages describe what this page can show from governed subject-scoped records. A lookup route does not mean a source was found; a lookup result does not mean bytes were saved; and a saved copy does not mean a fixed source version or a Check result exists.

Research frontier

Ready to investigate

None of the recorded identifier routes is marked routable.

Still unresolved

8 identifier routes and 11 reference hints remain research inputs rather than governed evidence.

Authority boundary

What this page establishes

It establishes what the retained Wikimedia observation contains and what investigation paths Counterpedia can describe from that material.

What it does not establish

A Wikidata statement is not automatically Counterpedia evidence.
A routable identifier is not a captured source.
A captured representation is not automatically a fixed source version.
A fixed source version is not automatically a Check result.
Graph proximity and reference counts are not support or corroboration.
A provider observation and candidate locator do not establish source bytes or support.

Presentation contract

Stage template: counterpedia.reader.profile.v1
Counterpedia composition: counterpedia.product.subject.profile.v1

Statements & recorded references

Open a statement to see the references attached to it. Context can limit when, where or how a statement applies. Recorded source URLs, identifier resolvers and source works describe where Wikidata points; none establishes source support or a completed Check.

Check execution is unavailable in this preview. Exact recorded locators remain available to inspect and open.

Relationship name unavailable: The Holocaust Industry (en)Reference count not carriedRecorded context: Relationship name unavailable: Reflections on the Exploitation of Jewish Suffering (en); Relationship name unavailable: English; Relationship name unavailable: named value unavailable in this releaseThis statement has context that cannot be fully shown here. An unresolved name or missing qualification can change how it should be understood.

Observation origin: Wikidata. References below are citations attached to this statement, not independently captured evidence.

About this property

The readable name for this property is unavailable here. Its code and exact recorded value are preserved; the code alone does not explain the relationship.

Wikidata property P1476

No exact source locator is carried for this statement in this view.

Qualifiers

Relationship name unavailable: Reflections on the Exploitation of Jewish Suffering (en)

Relationship name unavailable: English

Relationship name unavailable: named value unavailable in this release

Statement identity, reference hashes and carried detail

{
  "predicate": "P1476",
  "literalValue": {
    "language": "en",
    "text": "The Holocaust Industry"
  },
  "qualifiers": {
    "observedSnakCount": 3,
    "retainedSnaks": [
      {
        "propertyPid": "P1680",
        "datatype": "monolingualtext",
        "datavalue": {
          "type": "monolingualtext",
          "value": {
            "language": "en",
            "text": "Reflections on the Exploitation of Jewish Suffering"
          }
        },
        "snaktype": "value"
      },
      {
        "propertyPid": "P407",
        "valueLabel": "English",
        "datatype": "wikibase-item",
        "datavalue": {
          "type": "wikibase-entityid",
          "value": {
            "entity-type": "item",
            "id": "Q1860",
            "numeric-id": 1860
          }
        },
        "snaktype": "value"
      },
      {
        "propertyPid": "P7452",
        "datatype": "wikibase-item",
        "datavalue": {
          "type": "wikibase-entityid",
          "value": {
            "entity-type": "item",
            "id": "Q1294573",
            "numeric-id": 1294573
          }
        },
        "snaktype": "value"
      }
    ],
    "truncated": false
  }
}

Relationship name unavailable: Die Holocaustindustrie (de)Reference count not carriedRecorded context: Relationship name unavailable: Wie das Leiden der Juden ausgebeutet wird (de); Relationship name unavailable: GermanThis statement has context that cannot be fully shown here. An unresolved name or missing qualification can change how it should be understood.
Observation origin: Wikidata. References below are citations attached to this statement, not independently captured evidence.
About this property
The readable name for this property is unavailable here. Its code and exact recorded value are preserved; the code alone does not explain the relationship.
Wikidata property P1476
No exact source locator is carried for this statement in this view.
Qualifiers
Relationship name unavailable: Wie das Leiden der Juden ausgebeutet wird (de)
Relationship name unavailable: German
Statement identity, reference hashes and carried detail
```
{
  "predicate": "P1476",
  "literalValue": {
    "language": "de",
    "text": "Die Holocaustindustrie"
  },
  "qualifiers": {
    "observedSnakCount": 2,
    "retainedSnaks": [
      {
        "propertyPid": "P1680",
        "datatype": "monolingualtext",
        "datavalue": {
          "type": "monolingualtext",
          "value": {
            "language": "de",
            "text": "Wie das Leiden der Juden ausgebeutet wird"
          }
        },
        "snaktype": "value"
      },
      {
        "propertyPid": "P407",
        "valueLabel": "German",
        "datatype": "wikibase-item",
        "datavalue": {
          "type": "wikibase-entityid",
          "value": {
            "entity-type": "item",
            "id": "Q188",
            "numeric-id": 188
          }
        },
        "snaktype": "value"
      }
    ],
    "truncated": false
  }
}
```
different from: Holocaust IndustryReference count not carried
Observation origin: Wikidata. References below are citations attached to this statement, not independently captured evidence.
About this property
This names the relationship or attribute recorded by Wikidata. Any context shown beside it qualifies this particular statement.
Wikidata property P1889
No exact source locator is carried for this statement in this view.
Statement identity, reference hashes and carried detail
```
{
  "predicate": "P1889",
  "targetRef": "Q3494168",
  "targetLabel": "Holocaust Industry"
}
```
Relationship name unavailable: A Nation on Trial1 recorded reference
Observation origin: Wikidata. References below are citations attached to this statement, not independently captured evidence.
About this property
The readable name for this property is unavailable here. Its code and exact recorded value are preserved; the code alone does not explain the relationship.
Wikidata property P155
No exact source locator is carried for this statement in this view.
Statement identity, reference hashes and carried detail
```
{
  "predicate": "P155",
  "targetRef": "Q4658442",
  "targetLabel": "A Nation on Trial",
  "referencesSummary": {
    "referenceCount": 1,
    "referencePropertyPids": [
      "P143",
      "P4656"
    ],
    "referenceHashes": [
      "25e43f8ecfbb694ac94fcddd6ffd3003cddcd47d"
    ],
    "propertyPidSummaryTruncated": false,
    "referenceHashSummaryTruncated": false
  }
}
```
main subject: Holocaust studies1 recorded reference
Observation origin: Wikidata. References below are citations attached to this statement, not independently captured evidence.
About this property
This names the relationship or attribute recorded by Wikidata. Any context shown beside it qualifies this particular statement.
Wikidata property P921
No exact source locator is carried for this statement in this view.
Statement identity, reference hashes and carried detail
```
{
  "predicate": "P921",
  "targetRef": "Q1568255",
  "targetLabel": "Holocaust studies",
  "referencesSummary": {
    "referenceCount": 1,
    "referencePropertyPids": [
      "P143"
    ],
    "referenceHashes": [
      "fa278ebfc458360e5aed63d5058cca83c46134f1"
    ],
    "propertyPidSummaryTruncated": false,
    "referenceHashSummaryTruncated": false
  }
}
```
country of origin: United States1 recorded reference
Observation origin: Wikidata. References below are citations attached to this statement, not independently captured evidence.
About this property
This names the relationship or attribute recorded by Wikidata. Any context shown beside it qualifies this particular statement.
Wikidata property P495
No exact source locator is carried for this statement in this view.
Statement identity, reference hashes and carried detail
```
{
  "predicate": "P495",
  "targetRef": "Q30",
  "targetLabel": "United States",
  "referencesSummary": {
    "referenceCount": 1,
    "referencePropertyPids": [
      "P143",
      "P4656"
    ],
    "referenceHashes": [
      "25e43f8ecfbb694ac94fcddd6ffd3003cddcd47d"
    ],
    "propertyPidSummaryTruncated": false,
    "referenceHashSummaryTruncated": false
  }
}
```
genre: essay1 recorded reference
Observation origin: Wikidata. References below are citations attached to this statement, not independently captured evidence.
About this property
This names the relationship or attribute recorded by Wikidata. Any context shown beside it qualifies this particular statement.
Wikidata property P136
No exact source locator is carried for this statement in this view.
Statement identity, reference hashes and carried detail
```
{
  "predicate": "P136",
  "targetRef": "Q35760",
  "targetLabel": "essay",
  "referencesSummary": {
    "referenceCount": 1,
    "referencePropertyPids": [
      "P143"
    ],
    "referenceHashes": [
      "d5847b9b6032aa8b13dae3c2dfd9ed5d114d21b3"
    ],
    "propertyPidSummaryTruncated": false,
    "referenceHashSummaryTruncated": false
  }
}
```
Relationship name unavailable: The HolocaustReference count not carried
Observation origin: Wikidata. References below are citations attached to this statement, not independently captured evidence.
About this property
The readable name for this property is unavailable here. Its code and exact recorded value are preserved; the code alone does not explain the relationship.
Wikidata property P840
No exact source locator is carried for this statement in this view.
Statement identity, reference hashes and carried detail
```
{
  "predicate": "P840",
  "targetRef": "Q2763",
  "targetLabel": "The Holocaust"
}
```
Relationship name unavailable: L’Industrie de l’Holocauste (fr)Reference count not carriedRecorded context: Relationship name unavailable: réflexions sur l’exploitation de la souffrance des Juifs (fr); Relationship name unavailable: FrenchThis statement has context that cannot be fully shown here. An unresolved name or missing qualification can change how it should be understood.
Observation origin: Wikidata. References below are citations attached to this statement, not independently captured evidence.
About this property
The readable name for this property is unavailable here. Its code and exact recorded value are preserved; the code alone does not explain the relationship.
Wikidata property P1476
No exact source locator is carried for this statement in this view.
Qualifiers
Relationship name unavailable: réflexions sur l’exploitation de la souffrance des Juifs (fr)
Relationship name unavailable: French
Statement identity, reference hashes and carried detail
```
{
  "predicate": "P1476",
  "literalValue": {
    "language": "fr",
    "text": "L’Industrie de l’Holocauste"
  },
  "qualifiers": {
    "observedSnakCount": 2,
    "retainedSnaks": [
      {
        "propertyPid": "P1680",
        "datatype": "monolingualtext",
        "datavalue": {
          "type": "monolingualtext",
          "value": {
            "language": "fr",
            "text": "réflexions sur l’exploitation de la souffrance des Juifs"
          }
        },
        "snaktype": "value"
      },
      {
        "propertyPid": "P407",
        "valueLabel": "French",
        "datatype": "wikibase-item",
        "datavalue": {
          "type": "wikibase-entityid",
          "value": {
            "entity-type": "item",
            "id": "Q150",
            "numeric-id": 150
          }
        },
        "snaktype": "value"
      }
    ],
    "truncated": false
  }
}
```
Relationship name unavailable: Индустрия Холокоста (ru)Reference count not carriedRecorded context: Relationship name unavailable: размышления на тему эксплуатации еврейских страданий (ru)This statement has context that cannot be fully shown here. An unresolved name or missing qualification can change how it should be understood.
Observation origin: Wikidata. References below are citations attached to this statement, not independently captured evidence.
About this property
The readable name for this property is unavailable here. Its code and exact recorded value are preserved; the code alone does not explain the relationship.
Wikidata property P1476
No exact source locator is carried for this statement in this view.
Qualifiers
Relationship name unavailable: размышления на тему эксплуатации еврейских страданий (ru)
Statement identity, reference hashes and carried detail
```
{
  "predicate": "P1476",
  "literalValue": {
    "language": "ru",
    "text": "Индустрия Холокоста"
  },
  "qualifiers": {
    "observedSnakCount": 1,
    "retainedSnaks": [
      {
        "propertyPid": "P1680",
        "datatype": "monolingualtext",
        "datavalue": {
          "type": "monolingualtext",
          "value": {
            "language": "ru",
            "text": "размышления на тему эксплуатации еврейских страданий"
          }
        },
        "snaktype": "value"
      }
    ],
    "truncated": false
  }
}
```
Relationship name unavailable: De Holocaust-industrie (nl)Reference count not carriedRecorded context: Relationship name unavailable: bespiegelingen over de exploitatie van het joodse lijden (nl)This statement has context that cannot be fully shown here. An unresolved name or missing qualification can change how it should be understood.
Observation origin: Wikidata. References below are citations attached to this statement, not independently captured evidence.
About this property
The readable name for this property is unavailable here. Its code and exact recorded value are preserved; the code alone does not explain the relationship.
Wikidata property P1476
No exact source locator is carried for this statement in this view.
Qualifiers
Relationship name unavailable: bespiegelingen over de exploitatie van het joodse lijden (nl)
Statement identity, reference hashes and carried detail
```
{
  "predicate": "P1476",
  "literalValue": {
    "language": "nl",
    "text": "De Holocaust-industrie"
  },
  "qualifiers": {
    "observedSnakCount": 1,
    "retainedSnaks": [
      {
        "propertyPid": "P1680",
        "datatype": "monolingualtext",
        "datavalue": {
          "type": "monolingualtext",
          "value": {
            "language": "nl",
            "text": "bespiegelingen over de exploitatie van het joodse lijden"
          }
        },
        "snaktype": "value"
      }
    ],
    "truncated": false
  }
}
```
genre: non-fiction literatureReference count not carried
Observation origin: Wikidata. References below are citations attached to this statement, not independently captured evidence.
About this property
This names the relationship or attribute recorded by Wikidata. Any context shown beside it qualifies this particular statement.
Wikidata property P136
No exact source locator is carried for this statement in this view.
Statement identity, reference hashes and carried detail
```
{
  "predicate": "P136",
  "targetRef": "Q27801",
  "targetLabel": "non-fiction literature"
}
```
influenced by: The Holocaust in American Life1 recorded reference
Observation origin: Wikidata. References below are citations attached to this statement, not independently captured evidence.
About this property
This names the relationship or attribute recorded by Wikidata. Any context shown beside it qualifies this particular statement.
Wikidata property P737
No exact source locator is carried for this statement in this view.
Statement identity, reference hashes and carried detail
```
{
  "predicate": "P737",
  "targetRef": "Q7740012",
  "targetLabel": "The Holocaust in American Life",
  "referencesSummary": {
    "referenceCount": 1,
    "referencePropertyPids": [
      "P143",
      "P4656",
      "P813"
    ],
    "referenceHashes": [
      "bdb46284c964d51565ba463fb0510b95e8adc6cd"
    ],
    "propertyPidSummaryTruncated": false,
    "referenceHashSummaryTruncated": false
  }
}
```
instance of: literary workReference count not carried
Observation origin: Wikidata. References below are citations attached to this statement, not independently captured evidence.
About this property
This names the relationship or attribute recorded by Wikidata. Any context shown beside it qualifies this particular statement.
Wikidata property P31
No exact source locator is carried for this statement in this view.
Statement identity, reference hashes and carried detail
```
{
  "predicate": "P31",
  "targetRef": "Q7725634",
  "targetLabel": "literary work"
}
```
Relationship name unavailable: Beyond Chutzpah1 recorded reference
Observation origin: Wikidata. References below are citations attached to this statement, not independently captured evidence.
About this property
The readable name for this property is unavailable here. Its code and exact recorded value are preserved; the code alone does not explain the relationship.
Wikidata property P156
No exact source locator is carried for this statement in this view.
Statement identity, reference hashes and carried detail
```
{
  "predicate": "P156",
  "targetRef": "Q4899945",
  "targetLabel": "Beyond Chutzpah",
  "referencesSummary": {
    "referenceCount": 1,
    "referencePropertyPids": [
      "P143"
    ],
    "referenceHashes": [
      "fa278ebfc458360e5aed63d5058cca83c46134f1"
    ],
    "propertyPidSummaryTruncated": false,
    "referenceHashSummaryTruncated": false
  }
}
```
Relationship name unavailable: L'industria dell'Olocausto (it)Reference count not carriedRecorded context: Relationship name unavailable: Lo sfruttamento della sofferenza degli ebrei[ (it); Relationship name unavailable: ItalianThis statement has context that cannot be fully shown here. An unresolved name or missing qualification can change how it should be understood.
Observation origin: Wikidata. References below are citations attached to this statement, not independently captured evidence.
About this property
The readable name for this property is unavailable here. Its code and exact recorded value are preserved; the code alone does not explain the relationship.
Wikidata property P1476
No exact source locator is carried for this statement in this view.
Qualifiers
Relationship name unavailable: Lo sfruttamento della sofferenza degli ebrei[ (it)
Relationship name unavailable: Italian
Statement identity, reference hashes and carried detail
```
{
  "predicate": "P1476",
  "literalValue": {
    "language": "it",
    "text": "L'industria dell'Olocausto"
  },
  "qualifiers": {
    "observedSnakCount": 2,
    "retainedSnaks": [
      {
        "propertyPid": "P1680",
        "datatype": "monolingualtext",
        "datavalue": {
          "type": "monolingualtext",
          "value": {
            "language": "it",
            "text": "Lo sfruttamento della sofferenza degli ebrei["
          }
        },
        "snaktype": "value"
      },
      {
        "propertyPid": "P407",
        "valueLabel": "Italian",
        "datatype": "wikibase-item",
        "datavalue": {
          "type": "wikibase-entityid",
          "value": {
            "entity-type": "item",
            "id": "Q652",
            "numeric-id": 652
          }
        },
        "snaktype": "value"
      }
    ],
    "truncated": false
  }
}
```
Relationship name unavailable: Verso Books1 recorded reference
Observation origin: Wikidata. References below are citations attached to this statement, not independently captured evidence.
About this property
The readable name for this property is unavailable here. Its code and exact recorded value are preserved; the code alone does not explain the relationship.
Wikidata property P123
No exact source locator is carried for this statement in this view.
Statement identity, reference hashes and carried detail
```
{
  "predicate": "P123",
  "targetRef": "Q4010248",
  "targetLabel": "Verso Books",
  "referencesSummary": {
    "referenceCount": 1,
    "referencePropertyPids": [
      "P143"
    ],
    "referenceHashes": [
      "fa278ebfc458360e5aed63d5058cca83c46134f1"
    ],
    "propertyPidSummaryTruncated": false,
    "referenceHashSummaryTruncated": false
  }
}
```
Relationship name unavailable: Інду́стрія Голоко́сту (uk)Reference count not carriedRecorded context: Relationship name unavailable: UkrainianThis statement has context that cannot be fully shown here. An unresolved name or missing qualification can change how it should be understood.
Observation origin: Wikidata. References below are citations attached to this statement, not independently captured evidence.
About this property
The readable name for this property is unavailable here. Its code and exact recorded value are preserved; the code alone does not explain the relationship.
Wikidata property P1476
No exact source locator is carried for this statement in this view.
Qualifiers
Relationship name unavailable: Ukrainian
Statement identity, reference hashes and carried detail
```
{
  "predicate": "P1476",
  "literalValue": {
    "language": "uk",
    "text": "Інду́стрія Голоко́сту"
  },
  "qualifiers": {
    "observedSnakCount": 1,
    "retainedSnaks": [
      {
        "propertyPid": "P407",
        "valueLabel": "Ukrainian",
        "datatype": "wikibase-item",
        "datavalue": {
          "type": "wikibase-entityid",
          "value": {
            "entity-type": "item",
            "id": "Q8798",
            "numeric-id": 8798
          }
        },
        "snaktype": "value"
      }
    ],
    "truncated": false
  }
}
```
Relationship name unavailable: 20001 recorded reference
Observation origin: Wikidata. References below are citations attached to this statement, not independently captured evidence.
About this property
The readable name for this property is unavailable here. Its code and exact recorded value are preserved; the code alone does not explain the relationship.
Wikidata property P577
No exact source locator is carried for this statement in this view.
Statement identity, reference hashes and carried detail
```
{
  "predicate": "P577",
  "literalValue": {
    "after": 0,
    "before": 0,
    "calendarmodel": "http://www.wikidata.org/entity/Q1985727",
    "precision": 9,
    "time": "+2000-00-00T00:00:00Z",
    "timezone": 0
  },
  "referencesSummary": {
    "referenceCount": 1,
    "referencePropertyPids": [
      "P143"
    ],
    "referenceHashes": [
      "d4bd87b862b12d99d26e86472d44f26858dee639"
    ],
    "propertyPidSummaryTruncated": false,
    "referenceHashSummaryTruncated": false
  }
}
```
Relationship name unavailable: 2861 recorded reference
Observation origin: Wikidata. References below are citations attached to this statement, not independently captured evidence.
About this property
The readable name for this property is unavailable here. Its code and exact recorded value are preserved; the code alone does not explain the relationship.
Wikidata property P1104
No exact source locator is carried for this statement in this view.
Statement identity, reference hashes and carried detail
```
{
  "predicate": "P1104",
  "literalValue": {
    "amount": "+286",
    "unit": "1"
  },
  "referencesSummary": {
    "referenceCount": 1,
    "referencePropertyPids": [
      "P143",
      "P4656"
    ],
    "referenceHashes": [
      "d50e3bd627c22d885cdb61406b13d73758e78ac1"
    ],
    "propertyPidSummaryTruncated": false,
    "referenceHashSummaryTruncated": false
  }
}
```

author: Norman Finkelstein4 recorded references

Observation origin: Wikidata. References below are citations attached to this statement, not independently captured evidence.

About this property

This names the relationship or attribute recorded by Wikidata. Any context shown beside it qualifies this particular statement.

Wikidata property P50

No exact source locator is carried for this statement in this view.

Statement identity, reference hashes and carried detail

{
  "predicate": "P50",
  "targetRef": "Q160163",
  "targetLabel": "Norman Finkelstein",
  "referencesSummary": {
    "referenceCount": 4,
    "referencePropertyPids": [
      "P143"
    ],
    "referenceHashes": [
      "fa278ebfc458360e5aed63d5058cca83c46134f1",
      "288ab581e7d2d02995a26dfa8b091d96e78457fc",
      "d4bd87b862b12d99d26e86472d44f26858dee639",
      "d5847b9b6032aa8b13dae3c2dfd9ed5d114d21b3"
    ],
    "propertyPidSummaryTruncated": false,
    "referenceHashSummaryTruncated": false
  }
}

Relationship name unavailable: American English1 recorded reference
Observation origin: Wikidata. References below are citations attached to this statement, not independently captured evidence.
About this property
The readable name for this property is unavailable here. Its code and exact recorded value are preserved; the code alone does not explain the relationship.
Wikidata property P407
No exact source locator is carried for this statement in this view.
Statement identity, reference hashes and carried detail
```
{
  "predicate": "P407",
  "targetRef": "Q7976",
  "targetLabel": "American English",
  "referencesSummary": {
    "referenceCount": 1,
    "referencePropertyPids": [
      "P143"
    ],
    "referenceHashes": [
      "d4bd87b862b12d99d26e86472d44f26858dee639"
    ],
    "propertyPidSummaryTruncated": false,
    "referenceHashSummaryTruncated": false
  }
}
```
Relationship name unavailable: copyrightedReference count not carried
Observation origin: Wikidata. References below are citations attached to this statement, not independently captured evidence.
About this property
The readable name for this property is unavailable here. Its code and exact recorded value are preserved; the code alone does not explain the relationship.
Wikidata property P6216
No exact source locator is carried for this statement in this view.
Statement identity, reference hashes and carried detail
```
{
  "predicate": "P6216",
  "targetRef": "Q50423863",
  "targetLabel": "copyrighted"
}
```

Continue exploring

Inspect all recorded statements in pages →

Explore the relationship map Search for this name Browse other subjects Browse Literary work

Data and provenance

Wikidata entity IDs are external identifiers, not Counterpedia canonical subject identities. Rendering this page does not mint a governed identity. Release identities and artifact hashes identify the data used for this view; none establishes verification.

Provenance rows: 34
Acquisition repository: thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition
Acquisition revision: e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1, 891f24c5cca64aa69b1dc1b2150e991b940171b0
Provider identity · Observation origin: Wikidata · External entity ID: Q1768389 on Wikidata ↗
Served release: sha256:f33228901a35b0683356002a46df9ceb11f399d05f17abb5c7c78256cbf38ba7

No exact claim–source–Check association has been supplied to this page. Recorded references do not establish verification.

graph_membership != truth
graph_edge != support
repeated_identifier != independent_corroboration
projection != admission
Serving a published subset: joined entities + 1-hop neighborhood of 35,994 exact Wikipedia–Wikidata title matches.

Carried provenance rows

[
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_aliases",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:6c4ad7551a815aaafa38eff1d28f5aa08a560de0e5d1a9261bb7e8149cf5fe95",
      "output_file": "aliases.ndjson",
      "row_index": 67959,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-aliases@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_external_ids",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:559cdea7f610a91c3b3b9512b03afc31eedc59394a500d7a2b6221ef5e96d86c",
      "output_file": "identifiers.ndjson",
      "row_index": 1166968,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-identifiers@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_external_ids",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:535ed0072bac64004ac0f5a649e4af2b278fb61a18016d467eee2b76b8112ddd",
      "output_file": "identifiers.ndjson",
      "row_index": 1166970,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-identifiers@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_external_ids",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:1369d670d377fa0d43a14f69d7b4638dc4fd1ebee03fd8994d94480157c524a5",
      "output_file": "identifiers.ndjson",
      "row_index": 1166973,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-identifiers@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_external_ids",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:cb752ba446b1e9d4f060d01bcc038bc40b2a93c9be3ccb376c96440387908f36",
      "output_file": "identifiers.ndjson",
      "row_index": 1166971,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-identifiers@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_external_ids",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:6042e488d63ab6906168ec7f09b89bfdc071b02a7c05b0a0f3e23693e7891713",
      "output_file": "identifiers.ndjson",
      "row_index": 1166969,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-identifiers@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_external_ids",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:bd550154c0887a234188c671f9a10030aa85d124edf58908f79f2c3b4cc96795",
      "output_file": "identifiers.ndjson",
      "row_index": 1166974,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-identifiers@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_external_ids",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:81d4b970ac9802025a0b2df5e45c993ad13331793a9dab66f1e64729df169ef0",
      "output_file": "identifiers.ndjson",
      "row_index": 1166967,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-identifiers@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_external_ids",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:03e96a99cfa862a94b9d5e8ce7a665a4f193a77b86f9028c2198aff4feb22d99",
      "output_file": "identifiers.ndjson",
      "row_index": 1166972,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-identifiers@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_relationships",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:69a925bfd43aa8710b8f8c573cf1ace5f6df9c36fea400f9e309ef67a367e91d",
      "output_file": "relationships.ndjson",
      "row_index": 1625788,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-relationships@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_relationships",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:4ee96bd833ddb49c6fcfca3cb97d70341dd9c724b4959a5f87c86ac0edfcb4e1",
      "output_file": "relationships.ndjson",
      "row_index": 1625789,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-relationships@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_relationships",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:b1666ffcd548ea5a4dd4e694e9832c5c75a2f7b00fa4e741988a6631ffe25eac",
      "output_file": "relationships.ndjson",
      "row_index": 1625797,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-relationships@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_relationships",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:b5ad05a9141dc52b557ee7f04f9b28a59888f298c8a0e8cf571bd85e11df8be2",
      "output_file": "relationships.ndjson",
      "row_index": 1625795,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-relationships@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_relationships",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:e565c66954493ba288f977fe75446cb66ce1f8bb0fb3d3b2c7dbe8c2ff487a7e",
      "output_file": "relationships.ndjson",
      "row_index": 1625806,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-relationships@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_relationships",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:5db4590596274272255c2d8ef646bd0ec95d506d88ca4c0b9149d9c825d70734",
      "output_file": "relationships.ndjson",
      "row_index": 1625800,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-relationships@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_relationships",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:485792faca0a21c949cfe0ccc346a0efe5205aaff9e5bcc50025a8d283c1ed37",
      "output_file": "relationships.ndjson",
      "row_index": 1625787,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-relationships@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_relationships",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:4ed5b4811580fccc22ea85d000da59d2c4415e41a1155af1e9b0ff190cbf369d",
      "output_file": "relationships.ndjson",
      "row_index": 1625805,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-relationships@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_relationships",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:7c5b82e43488143cf4b8467bdf03163adada28e2357b47b10da66d6c62fcdcfa",
      "output_file": "relationships.ndjson",
      "row_index": 1625790,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-relationships@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_relationships",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:ec6339afd0a877dbeb19ec3a4f33f8302e240373d52de1173e362f1329ae42f6",
      "output_file": "relationships.ndjson",
      "row_index": 1625793,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-relationships@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_relationships",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:1ae316f4258fe1913f33a75ffb2cabf9fee02ea64470f98a5d559f7b68acf64a",
      "output_file": "relationships.ndjson",
      "row_index": 1625792,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-relationships@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_relationships",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:ee1b69f3dcf9b1623b0f33ad379950ccaa5ee53105859df1f844971a1b674395",
      "output_file": "relationships.ndjson",
      "row_index": 1625786,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-relationships@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_relationships",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:687fee372e6ea8647ffeb34d78af5399cae99a06e53b595e281bbf71f5bfb0a7",
      "output_file": "relationships.ndjson",
      "row_index": 1625804,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-relationships@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_relationships",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:21bd8658b3fca8f79760230bde613910ee396c5dc644bc2ec01b8b59e1e8b38d",
      "output_file": "relationships.ndjson",
      "row_index": 1625798,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-relationships@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_relationships",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:2a01fa9441d6dc46866ed13a67e9db437c942aa3ce488e8ee4cd246d425b32d2",
      "output_file": "relationships.ndjson",
      "row_index": 1625796,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-relationships@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_relationships",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:6ad69e321511cbe7c1236d4f75309c5f4bbc41296ce60ec59d3eae2f4c876bab",
      "output_file": "relationships.ndjson",
      "row_index": 1625791,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-relationships@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_relationships",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:ae6e2050c93659a842bfdf170b49c01814450fd3f04b2f4550ead6d30981380e",
      "output_file": "relationships.ndjson",
      "row_index": 1625785,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-relationships@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_relationships",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:19d63aea0feff3ff28eefbd528fbae0f68ebfe17e69f7a8918e13c03f587b5a7",
      "output_file": "relationships.ndjson",
      "row_index": 1625794,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-relationships@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_relationships",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:9e8b51d9fe3bd70a453e55e4064737cb6b4ef56033992b43e3a17bb5a685b09a",
      "output_file": "relationships.ndjson",
      "row_index": 1625802,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-relationships@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_relationships",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:d64eedd6feedff44358753319a2ab210fe46ef2fa9579f09b3c1b2974667c361",
      "output_file": "relationships.ndjson",
      "row_index": 1625784,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-relationships@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_relationships",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:c90def725f58fa644c8388287c3462ac109679474bb9efc30d8c5fb7bff7dfdd",
      "output_file": "relationships.ndjson",
      "row_index": 1625801,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-relationships@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_relationships",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:b494e462e88874464b9a5897b819abf81994fa449a207e07da064c34bcac61f8",
      "output_file": "relationships.ndjson",
      "row_index": 1625799,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-relationships@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_relationships",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:0fbf0f2f608b5d3fa50a4cc6276a9332257b1276b595f830bbfa99aa8a786055",
      "output_file": "relationships.ndjson",
      "row_index": 1625803,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-relationships@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "e6add6a4d8e1668a9ac486407e52974724563ce1",
      "family": "wikidata_enwiki_sitelinks",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:9f708112be9ef97c002c2c709960ab2354b5b5f22ff184cb188d8b7f0236aa26",
      "output_file": "wikipedia_sitelinks.ndjson",
      "row_index": 61081,
      "snapshot_id": "wikidata-widen0-848k-sitelinks@2026-08-24"
    }
  },
  {
    "family": "wikimedia_graph_row",
    "detail": {
      "acquisition_repo": "thelaplage/counterpedia-acquisition",
      "acquisition_revision": "891f24c5cca64aa69b1dc1b2150e991b940171b0",
      "family": "wikipedia_wikidata_join",
      "input_row_digest": "sha256:1a21f2a04e5ffc37e88bdd77c63799dfc29d4908a610ec6e0ba280e6665dd7f7",
      "output_file": "wikipedia_wikidata_links.ndjson",
      "row_index": 31684,
      "snapshot_id": "wikimedia-demo-join0@2026-08-28"
    }
  }
]

Classification identities

[
  {
    "classQid": "Q7725634",
    "label": "literary work",
    "href": "/browse/types/Q7725634"
  }
]

Wikidata content CC0; Wikipedia titles CC BY-SA — attribution.