CounterpediaExplore knowledge. Follow the sources.

R. Paul Butler

Relationships observed in Wikidata. Connections do not establish verification or source support.

Release: sha256:f33228901a35b0683356002a46df9ceb11f399d05f17abb5c7c78256cbf38ba7

Provider: Wikidata · graph projection only.

OBSERVED · GRAPH-PROJECTION · NOT ADMITTED · NOT VERIFIED · NOT SUPPORT

Edge identity is the provider property id (for example P31). It is not a Counterpedia predicate.

Development requests are not available on this deployment. The observed entity and its graph links remain readable.

Relationships of R. Paul Butler

Show relationship types (drawing only; the text lists are unaffected)
image (Observed provider relationships)member of (Observed provider relationships)given name (Observed provider relationships)award received (Observed provider relationships)place of birth (Observed provider relationships)educated at (Observed provider relationships)award received (Observed provider relationships)occupation (Observed provider relationships)member of (Observed provider relationships)employer (Observed provider relationships)instance of (Observed provider relationships)award received (Observed provider relationships)sex or gender (Observed provider relationships)country of citizenship (Observed provider relationships)given name (Observed provider relationships)Relationship label not yet available (Observed provider relationships)date of birth (Observed provider relationships)family name (Observed provider relationships)Relationship label not yet available (Observed provider relationships)Relationship label not yet available (Observed provider relationships)R. Paul Butler — Wikidata entity (Q1387698)R. Paul ButlerWIKIDATA ENTITYR. Paul Butler.jpg — Literal value (wikidata:literal:0:R. Paul Butler.jpg)R. PaulButler.jpgLITERAL VALUEInternational Astronomical Union — Wikidata entity (Q6867)InternationalAstronomical…WIKIDATA ENTITYPaul — Wikidata entity (Q4925623)PaulWIKIDATA ENTITYFellow of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences — Wikidata entity (Q52382875)Fellow of theAmerican Academ…WIKIDATA ENTITYSan Diego — Wikidata entity (Q16552)San DiegoWIKIDATA ENTITYSan Francisco State University — Wikidata entity (Q1256981)San FranciscoState UniversityWIKIDATA ENTITYBeatrice M. Tinsley Prize — Wikidata entity (Q813239)Beatrice M.Tinsley PrizeWIKIDATA ENTITYastronomer — Wikidata entity (Q11063)astronomerWIKIDATA ENTITYAmerican Academy of Arts and Sciences — Wikidata entity (Q463303)American Academyof Arts and…WIKIDATA ENTITYDepartment of Terrestrial Magnetism — Wikidata entity (Q30258396)Department ofTerrestrial…WIKIDATA ENTITYhuman — Wikidata entity (Q5)humanWIKIDATA ENTITYHenry Draper Medal — Wikidata entity (Q746633)Henry DraperMedalWIKIDATA ENTITYmale — Wikidata entity (Q6581097)maleWIKIDATA ENTITYUnited States — Wikidata entity (Q30)United StatesWIKIDATA ENTITYRobert — Wikidata entity (Q4927937)RobertWIKIDATA ENTITYhttps://epl.carnegiescience.edu/people/r-paul-butler — Literal value (wikidata:literal:15:https://epl.carnegiescience.edu/people/r-paul-butler)https://epl.carnegiescience.edu…LITERAL VALUE1960 — Literal value (wikidata:literal:16:1960)1960LITERAL VALUEButler — Wikidata entity (Q2664624)ButlerWIKIDATA ENTITYHD 114783 b — Wikidata entity (Q115885)HD 114783 bWIKIDATA ENTITY

Legend

  • Governed record relationships (solid)
  • Countergraph traversal (dashed)
  • Countergraph evidence (dotted)
  • Observed provider relationships (dash-dot)
  • Structurally derived (sparse dots)

Node shape identifies node kind only. Size, color, and position carry no meaning beyond hop distance from the root.

A line means a supported artifact carried an explicit structured relation. It does not mean the relation is true, admitted, verified, or authoritative.

Graph as text

Nodes (20)

  • R. Paul Butler — Wikidata entity
    Technical details
    node_id
    wikidata:entity:Q1387698
    stable_ref
    Q1387698
    node_kind
    wikidata_entity
    plane
    provider_observed
    qid
    Q1387698
    provider
    wikidata
    entity_href
    /entries/wikidata/Q1387698
  • R. Paul Butler.jpg — Literal value
    Technical details
    node_id
    wikidata:literal:0:R. Paul Butler.jpg
    stable_ref
    wikidata:literal:0:R. Paul Butler.jpg
    node_kind
    wikidata_literal
    plane
    provider_observed
  • International Astronomical Union — Wikidata entity
    Technical details
    node_id
    wikidata:entity:Q6867
    stable_ref
    Q6867
    node_kind
    wikidata_entity
    plane
    provider_observed
    qid
    Q6867
    provider
    wikidata
    entity_href
    /entries/wikidata/Q6867
  • Paul — Wikidata entity
    Technical details
    node_id
    wikidata:entity:Q4925623
    stable_ref
    Q4925623
    node_kind
    wikidata_entity
    plane
    provider_observed
    qid
    Q4925623
    provider
    wikidata
    entity_href
    /entries/wikidata/Q4925623
  • Fellow of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences — Wikidata entity
    Technical details
    node_id
    wikidata:entity:Q52382875
    stable_ref
    Q52382875
    node_kind
    wikidata_entity
    plane
    provider_observed
    qid
    Q52382875
    provider
    wikidata
    entity_href
    /entries/wikidata/Q52382875
  • San Diego — Wikidata entity
    Technical details
    node_id
    wikidata:entity:Q16552
    stable_ref
    Q16552
    node_kind
    wikidata_entity
    plane
    provider_observed
    qid
    Q16552
    provider
    wikidata
    entity_href
    /entries/wikidata/Q16552
  • San Francisco State University — Wikidata entity
    Technical details
    node_id
    wikidata:entity:Q1256981
    stable_ref
    Q1256981
    node_kind
    wikidata_entity
    plane
    provider_observed
    qid
    Q1256981
    provider
    wikidata
    entity_href
    /entries/wikidata/Q1256981
  • Beatrice M. Tinsley Prize — Wikidata entity
    Technical details
    node_id
    wikidata:entity:Q813239
    stable_ref
    Q813239
    node_kind
    wikidata_entity
    plane
    provider_observed
    qid
    Q813239
    provider
    wikidata
    entity_href
    /entries/wikidata/Q813239
  • astronomer — Wikidata entity
    Technical details
    node_id
    wikidata:entity:Q11063
    stable_ref
    Q11063
    node_kind
    wikidata_entity
    plane
    provider_observed
    qid
    Q11063
    provider
    wikidata
    entity_href
    /entries/wikidata/Q11063
  • American Academy of Arts and Sciences — Wikidata entity
    Technical details
    node_id
    wikidata:entity:Q463303
    stable_ref
    Q463303
    node_kind
    wikidata_entity
    plane
    provider_observed
    qid
    Q463303
    provider
    wikidata
    entity_href
    /entries/wikidata/Q463303
  • Department of Terrestrial Magnetism — Wikidata entity
    Technical details
    node_id
    wikidata:entity:Q30258396
    stable_ref
    Q30258396
    node_kind
    wikidata_entity
    plane
    provider_observed
    qid
    Q30258396
    provider
    wikidata
    entity_href
    /entries/wikidata/Q30258396
  • human — Wikidata entity
    Technical details
    node_id
    wikidata:entity:Q5
    stable_ref
    Q5
    node_kind
    wikidata_entity
    plane
    provider_observed
    qid
    Q5
    provider
    wikidata
    entity_href
    /entries/wikidata/Q5
  • Henry Draper Medal — Wikidata entity
    Technical details
    node_id
    wikidata:entity:Q746633
    stable_ref
    Q746633
    node_kind
    wikidata_entity
    plane
    provider_observed
    qid
    Q746633
    provider
    wikidata
    entity_href
    /entries/wikidata/Q746633
  • male — Wikidata entity
    Technical details
    node_id
    wikidata:entity:Q6581097
    stable_ref
    Q6581097
    node_kind
    wikidata_entity
    plane
    provider_observed
    qid
    Q6581097
    provider
    wikidata
    entity_href
    /entries/wikidata/Q6581097
  • United States — Wikidata entity
    Technical details
    node_id
    wikidata:entity:Q30
    stable_ref
    Q30
    node_kind
    wikidata_entity
    plane
    provider_observed
    qid
    Q30
    provider
    wikidata
    entity_href
    /entries/wikidata/Q30
  • Robert — Wikidata entity
    Technical details
    node_id
    wikidata:entity:Q4927937
    stable_ref
    Q4927937
    node_kind
    wikidata_entity
    plane
    provider_observed
    qid
    Q4927937
    provider
    wikidata
    entity_href
    /entries/wikidata/Q4927937
  • https://epl.carnegiescience.edu/people/r-paul-butler — Literal value
    Technical details
    node_id
    wikidata:literal:15:https://epl.carnegiescience.edu/people/r-paul-butler
    stable_ref
    wikidata:literal:15:https://epl.carnegiescience.edu/people/r-paul-butler
    node_kind
    wikidata_literal
    plane
    provider_observed
  • 1960 — Literal value
    Technical details
    node_id
    wikidata:literal:16:1960
    stable_ref
    wikidata:literal:16:1960
    node_kind
    wikidata_literal
    plane
    provider_observed
  • Butler — Wikidata entity
    Technical details
    node_id
    wikidata:entity:Q2664624
    stable_ref
    Q2664624
    node_kind
    wikidata_entity
    plane
    provider_observed
    qid
    Q2664624
    provider
    wikidata
    entity_href
    /entries/wikidata/Q2664624
  • HD 114783 b — Wikidata entity
    Technical details
    node_id
    wikidata:entity:Q115885
    stable_ref
    Q115885
    node_kind
    wikidata_entity
    plane
    provider_observed
    qid
    Q115885
    provider
    wikidata
    entity_href
    /entries/wikidata/Q115885

Edges (20)

  • R. Paul Butler — image → R. Paul Butler.jpg — Observed provider relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    P18
    predicate_ref
    wikidata:property:P18
    provider
    wikidata
    provider_direction
    outgoing
    plane
    provider_observed
    edge_id
    wikidata:relation:0:P18
    release_ref
    sha256:f33228901a35b0683356002a46df9ceb11f399d05f17abb5c7c78256cbf38ba7
  • R. Paul Butler — member of → International Astronomical Union — Observed provider relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    P463
    predicate_ref
    wikidata:property:P463
    provider
    wikidata
    provider_direction
    outgoing
    plane
    provider_observed
    edge_id
    wikidata:relation:1:P463
    release_ref
    sha256:f33228901a35b0683356002a46df9ceb11f399d05f17abb5c7c78256cbf38ba7
  • R. Paul Butler — given name → Paul — Observed provider relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    P735
    predicate_ref
    wikidata:property:P735
    provider
    wikidata
    provider_direction
    outgoing
    plane
    provider_observed
    edge_id
    wikidata:relation:2:P735
    release_ref
    sha256:f33228901a35b0683356002a46df9ceb11f399d05f17abb5c7c78256cbf38ba7
  • R. Paul Butler — award received → Fellow of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences — Observed provider relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    P166
    predicate_ref
    wikidata:property:P166
    provider
    wikidata
    provider_direction
    outgoing
    plane
    provider_observed
    edge_id
    wikidata:relation:3:P166
    release_ref
    sha256:f33228901a35b0683356002a46df9ceb11f399d05f17abb5c7c78256cbf38ba7
  • R. Paul Butler — place of birth → San Diego — Observed provider relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    P19
    predicate_ref
    wikidata:property:P19
    provider
    wikidata
    provider_direction
    outgoing
    plane
    provider_observed
    edge_id
    wikidata:relation:4:P19
    release_ref
    sha256:f33228901a35b0683356002a46df9ceb11f399d05f17abb5c7c78256cbf38ba7
  • R. Paul Butler — educated at → San Francisco State University — Observed provider relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    P69
    predicate_ref
    wikidata:property:P69
    provider
    wikidata
    provider_direction
    outgoing
    plane
    provider_observed
    edge_id
    wikidata:relation:5:P69
    release_ref
    sha256:f33228901a35b0683356002a46df9ceb11f399d05f17abb5c7c78256cbf38ba7
  • R. Paul Butler — award received → Beatrice M. Tinsley Prize — Observed provider relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    P166
    predicate_ref
    wikidata:property:P166
    provider
    wikidata
    provider_direction
    outgoing
    plane
    provider_observed
    edge_id
    wikidata:relation:6:P166
    release_ref
    sha256:f33228901a35b0683356002a46df9ceb11f399d05f17abb5c7c78256cbf38ba7
  • R. Paul Butler — occupation → astronomer — Observed provider relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    P106
    predicate_ref
    wikidata:property:P106
    provider
    wikidata
    provider_direction
    outgoing
    plane
    provider_observed
    edge_id
    wikidata:relation:7:P106
    release_ref
    sha256:f33228901a35b0683356002a46df9ceb11f399d05f17abb5c7c78256cbf38ba7
  • R. Paul Butler — member of → American Academy of Arts and Sciences — Observed provider relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    P463
    predicate_ref
    wikidata:property:P463
    provider
    wikidata
    provider_direction
    outgoing
    plane
    provider_observed
    edge_id
    wikidata:relation:8:P463
    release_ref
    sha256:f33228901a35b0683356002a46df9ceb11f399d05f17abb5c7c78256cbf38ba7
  • R. Paul Butler — employer → Department of Terrestrial Magnetism — Observed provider relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    P108
    predicate_ref
    wikidata:property:P108
    provider
    wikidata
    provider_direction
    outgoing
    plane
    provider_observed
    edge_id
    wikidata:relation:9:P108
    release_ref
    sha256:f33228901a35b0683356002a46df9ceb11f399d05f17abb5c7c78256cbf38ba7
  • R. Paul Butler — instance of → human — Observed provider relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    P31
    predicate_ref
    wikidata:property:P31
    provider
    wikidata
    provider_direction
    outgoing
    plane
    provider_observed
    edge_id
    wikidata:relation:10:P31
    release_ref
    sha256:f33228901a35b0683356002a46df9ceb11f399d05f17abb5c7c78256cbf38ba7
  • R. Paul Butler — award received → Henry Draper Medal — Observed provider relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    P166
    predicate_ref
    wikidata:property:P166
    provider
    wikidata
    provider_direction
    outgoing
    plane
    provider_observed
    edge_id
    wikidata:relation:11:P166
    release_ref
    sha256:f33228901a35b0683356002a46df9ceb11f399d05f17abb5c7c78256cbf38ba7
  • R. Paul Butler — sex or gender → male — Observed provider relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    P21
    predicate_ref
    wikidata:property:P21
    provider
    wikidata
    provider_direction
    outgoing
    plane
    provider_observed
    edge_id
    wikidata:relation:12:P21
    release_ref
    sha256:f33228901a35b0683356002a46df9ceb11f399d05f17abb5c7c78256cbf38ba7
  • R. Paul Butler — country of citizenship → United States — Observed provider relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    P27
    predicate_ref
    wikidata:property:P27
    provider
    wikidata
    provider_direction
    outgoing
    plane
    provider_observed
    edge_id
    wikidata:relation:13:P27
    release_ref
    sha256:f33228901a35b0683356002a46df9ceb11f399d05f17abb5c7c78256cbf38ba7
  • R. Paul Butler — given name → Robert — Observed provider relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    P735
    predicate_ref
    wikidata:property:P735
    provider
    wikidata
    provider_direction
    outgoing
    plane
    provider_observed
    edge_id
    wikidata:relation:14:P735
    release_ref
    sha256:f33228901a35b0683356002a46df9ceb11f399d05f17abb5c7c78256cbf38ba7
  • R. Paul Butler — Relationship label not yet available → https://epl.carnegiescience.edu/people/r-paul-butler — Observed provider relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    P856
    predicate_ref
    wikidata:property:P856
    provider
    wikidata
    provider_direction
    outgoing
    plane
    provider_observed
    edge_id
    wikidata:relation:15:P856
    release_ref
    sha256:f33228901a35b0683356002a46df9ceb11f399d05f17abb5c7c78256cbf38ba7
  • R. Paul Butler — date of birth → 1960 — Observed provider relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    P569
    predicate_ref
    wikidata:property:P569
    provider
    wikidata
    provider_direction
    outgoing
    plane
    provider_observed
    edge_id
    wikidata:relation:16:P569
    release_ref
    sha256:f33228901a35b0683356002a46df9ceb11f399d05f17abb5c7c78256cbf38ba7
  • R. Paul Butler — family name → Butler — Observed provider relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    P734
    predicate_ref
    wikidata:property:P734
    provider
    wikidata
    provider_direction
    outgoing
    plane
    provider_observed
    edge_id
    wikidata:relation:17:P734
    release_ref
    sha256:f33228901a35b0683356002a46df9ceb11f399d05f17abb5c7c78256cbf38ba7
  • HD 114783 b — Relationship label not yet available → R. Paul Butler — Observed provider relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    P61
    predicate_ref
    wikidata:property:P61
    provider
    wikidata
    provider_direction
    incoming
    plane
    provider_observed
    edge_id
    wikidata:relation:18:P61
    release_ref
    sha256:f33228901a35b0683356002a46df9ceb11f399d05f17abb5c7c78256cbf38ba7
  • Henry Draper Medal — Relationship label not yet available → R. Paul Butler — Observed provider relationships
    Technical details
    machine_predicate
    P1346
    predicate_ref
    wikidata:property:P1346
    provider
    wikidata
    provider_direction
    incoming
    plane
    provider_observed
    edge_id
    wikidata:relation:19:P1346
    release_ref
    sha256:f33228901a35b0683356002a46df9ceb11f399d05f17abb5c7c78256cbf38ba7

Reader shortcuts (not graph edges) (0)

    Unresolved references (0)

      Frontier (0)